By the conclusion of the 2025 season, Luke Weaver transitioned from being a reliable asset in New York Yankees manager Aaron Boone’s bullpen to a pitcher whose performance was scrutinized in crucial moments. However, this shift doesn’t deter the Yankees from looking to re-establish their connection with the self-described “ferocious jungle cat.”
Recent reports indicate that the Yankees have shown a “genuine” interest in bringing Weaver back into the fold, and the 32-year-old reliever himself expresses enthusiasm about reuniting with the team. Although discussions are still in the early stages, the right-handed pitcher is evaluating multiple options, drawing attention from approximately ten teams this offseason. While he has previously expressed a willingness to return to a starting role—boasting a record of 106 career starts—no franchises have yet signaled an intention to utilize him in that capacity.
The relief market this offseason has seen notable activity, with established names such as Devin Williams, Edwin Díaz, and Kenley Jansen securing deals, while Pete Fairbanks and Weaver remain among the top relievers still seeking new homes. Weaver is poised to embrace any high-leverage role, including closing or serving as a vital fireman in the bullpen, similar to his contributions during 2024 and 2025.
Yankees general manager Brian Cashman reiterated the organization’s imperative to bolster their bullpen, stating the desire to augment the mix of reliable arms to manage critical innings. Currently, the Yankees’ relief core comprises David Bednar, Camilo Doval, Fernando Cruz, and Tim Hill, with Jake Bird likely rounding out the group. Cashman remarked on the need for quality relievers who can handle the pressure of decisive moments, especially following the loss of some valuable pitchers.
The Yankees have also enlisted right-hander Cade Winquest from the Rule 5 draft, positioning him as a potential relief option, although Rule 5 selections commonly face uncertainty regarding their future with the team. Boone mentioned that left-hander Brent Headrick could take on a more prominent role next season. Meanwhile, Ryan Yarbrough is anticipated to serve as a bullpen asset, though he is expected to start the season in the rotation.
With room in the bullpen for reinforcements, Weaver’s capabilities could significantly contribute to the Yankees’ efforts. While Doval possesses the potential for dominance, his command has waned over the last two seasons, a challenge mirrored by Cruz, who boasts an impressive splitter but struggles with consistency. Weaver’s strengths—boasting impressive chase and whiff rates—make him an ideal candidate for a team in search of arms that can effectively challenge hitters.
Despite a tough 2025 season, which was marred by a left hamstring strain and subsequent struggles with mechanics, Weaver previously demonstrated his prowess on the mound, evidenced by a stellar 2.65 FIP prior to his injury. If those obstacles are behind him, there is strong potential for him to reclaim his status as one of the league’s top relievers, as seen in his breakout 2024 season.
One notable consideration regarding Weaver’s potential return revolves around the Yankees’ historical reluctance to invest in high-profile free-agent relievers in recent years, with significant long-term contracts being rare since the signings of Adam Ottavino and Zack Britton in 2019. However, with the current state of the Yankees bullpen appearing subpar, re-signing Weaver could pose a logical solution. Yet, given past patterns, it remains plausible that he may find himself donning a different uniform come 2026.