American Primeval, a new miniseries on Netflix, showcases a fresh perspective on the Western genre, diverging from the stylings of Taylor Sheridan. The series reflects on the dark chapters of American history, particularly the impact of white expansion on Native peoples and the violent legacy of Mormon settlers in 1857 Utah Territory. Unlike some contemporary Westerns, which often romanticize their subjects, American Primeval dives into the gritty reality of this tumultuous time.
This six-episode series weaves together three significant narratives: the conflict between Mormon leader Brigham Young and mountain man Jim Bridger, the developing relationship between tracker Isaac Reed and East Coast woman Sara Rowell, and the Shoshone tribe’s survival against violent incursions by Mormons. While the individual storylines exhibit varying levels of engagement, they collectively highlight the brutality embedded in the American narrative.
The series benefits from strong performances, particularly from Shea Whigham as Jim Bridger, who delivers a nuanced portrayal of a man caught between fading traditions and rising aggressions. The tension between Bridger and Young serves as one of the show’s highlights, bringing an intense, compelling friction to the story. It skillfully critiques the role of religion in shaping American identity, suggesting that the violence of the past persists in contemporary forms.
Taylor Kitsch and Betty Gilpin’s characters, Isaac and Sara, introduce a more familiar framework reminiscent of other revisionist westerns. Their interactions offer moments of levity amidst the darker themes, though their storyline feels somewhat predictable, following a well-trodden path of character arcs.
On the other hand, the subplot focusing on the Shoshone tribe brings necessary visibility to Indigenous perspectives, but may leave viewers wanting more depth in character development. The portrayal of the violence and despair faced by Native communities is evident but could have benefitted from a more profound exploration of their individual narratives.
Overall, American Primeval addresses complex themes and sheds light on the gruesome reality of America’s westward expansion. While it presents an uneven experience, the series does make a commendable effort to address historical truths and foster conversations around them.
As audiences engage with this fresh take on the Western genre, it encourages a broader reflection on the intricacies of American identity and history. By tackling difficult subjects within a compelling narrative framework, American Primeval has the potential to resonate with viewers looking for deeper storytelling in a traditionally romanticized genre.