In a recent segment of “The Five,” Fox News host Jesse Watters made controversial remarks about Olympic gymnast Simone Biles, labeling her as “mentally weak” in the context of a public spat between Biles and right-wing activist Riley Gaines. This dispute arose after Biles criticized Gaines for bullying a transgender teenager on social media. Gaines, a former NCAA swimmer, misgendered the young athlete amid a tirade about inclusivity and sports, which prompted Biles to call out Gaines for her harmful rhetoric.
Biles, a staunch advocate for mental health awareness following her withdrawal from several events during the Tokyo Olympics due to mental health concerns, referred to Gaines’ actions as detrimental to the trans community. In her response online, she suggested that Gaines focus on uplifting marginalized groups rather than engaging in bullying.
Watters’ comments drew criticism not only for their content but also for their potential to perpetuate harmful stereotypes surrounding mental health. Licensed clinical social worker Monica Cwynar highlighted that labeling Biles’ mental health struggles as weakness undermines her courage to address these issues publicly. Cwynar noted that mental health challenges are complex and often invisible, which further stigmatizes those who experience them.
Moreover, Cwynar pointed out that Biles, as a Black female athlete, faces additional scrutiny that can exacerbate feelings of isolation and shame. She argued that embracing conversations around mental well-being, rather than mocking them, is essential for performance and should be viewed as a strength.
Biles’ case serves as a reminder of the pressing need to foster a culture where discussing mental health is normalized and valued rather than ridiculed. Encouraging positive engagement with mental health can empower individuals to seek the help they need, challenging the stigma that often accompanies these discussions.
This situation underscores the importance of supporting mental health advocacy and recognizing the nuances of individual experiences, especially for marginalized groups in sports. Biles’ continued fight for mental health awareness offers hope for a more inclusive and understanding environment in athletics and beyond.