The Detroit Tigers have seen unexpected success with former New York Yankees players Gleyber Torres and Jahmai Jones this season. Both have exceeded expectations, with Torres expressing interest in potentially returning next season, and Jones being considered a valuable, cost-effective asset for the team. However, the Tigers’ success with these former Yankees players has sparked speculation about further acquisitions from the Bronx Bombers, specifically shortstop Anthony Volpe.
Jim Riley, a YouTuber from BALLCAP Sports, recently speculated that Volpe could be on the move after the 2025 season, identifying several potential trade destinations, including the Padres, Pirates, Giants, Guardians, and even the Tigers. While the notion of Volpe leaving the Yankees is primarily speculative, the idea of him joining the Tigers raises eyebrows, especially given his struggles.
Despite being highly touted as the successor to Derek Jeter, Volpe has faced significant criticism for underperforming, batting just .208 with a .667 OPS while ranking as one of the league’s weaker defensive shortstops. Despite these challenges, Yankees management, led by Aaron Boone and Brian Cashman, have stood firmly behind Volpe.
Even hypothetically, if the Yankees considered a trade, it seems unlikely the Tigers would express serious interest. Their infield needs are not aligned with acquiring Volpe, especially since their No. 2 overall prospect, also a shortstop, is nearing a major league debut. Additionally, the idea of forgoing valuable prospect capital for Volpe’s underwhelming performance does not align with Detroit’s strategic interests.
Ultimately, while there may be speculation about Volpe’s future with the Yankees, it is highly improbable that the Tigers would pursue a deal. Instead, it appears more likely that Volpe will remain with his current team, at least until free agency presents its own opportunities. The Tigers are better positioned to focus on cultivating their existing talent and making strategic decisions that align more closely with their future goals.