J.J. McCarthy’s 2025 season with the Minnesota Vikings has been a tumultuous experience defined by injuries, inconsistencies, and moments of brilliance in his inaugural year as a starter. After missing his entire rookie season in 2024 due to injury, McCarthy has played nine games this year, completing 57.3% of his passes for 1,450 yards, accumulating 11 touchdowns and 12 interceptions, while also showing his dual-threat ability with four rushing touchdowns. Despite these flashes of potential, the struggles of the Vikings’ offense have often coincided with McCarthy’s uneven performances.
The season began with optimism, as McCarthy led the Vikings to a comeback victory over the Chicago Bears in Week 1, passing for 143 yards and two touchdowns, while adding a rushing score. Unfortunately, a high ankle sprain in Week 2 sidelined him for five consecutive games. Since returning, he has faced additional challenges, including a concussion that prevented him from playing in Week 13 and a hairline fracture in his throwing hand that kept him out of action in Week 17.
Nevertheless, McCarthy has demonstrated resilience, leading the Vikings to three consecutive wins late in the season and is expected to make his return for the regular-season finale. His performance during this stretch has sparked discussions about his viability as the starting quarterback moving into 2026. Supporters of McCarthy advocate for his retention, highlighting his resilience and the potential for significant improvement with a full offseason to refine his mechanics and decision-making. Conversely, critics point to his low completion percentage and turnover concerns, suggesting that the Vikings should consider veteran options to add competition.
According to a report from The Athletic by Dianna Russini, the Vikings are actively exploring established quarterback options through trades or free agency this offseason, although they plan to retain McCarthy as their starter. Head coach Kevin O’Connell and general manager Kwesi Adofo-Mensah are reportedly open to bringing in a seasoned quarterback to compete with McCarthy.
Star wide receiver Justin Jefferson has voiced his support for McCarthy, indicating his belief that the young quarterback can grow into a leading role, while also acknowledging the need for offseason work to strengthen their rapport.
As the Vikings finish their 2025 campaign against the Green Bay Packers this Sunday at home, with kickoff scheduled for 1 p.m. ET, the game will serve as an important evaluation opportunity for McCarthy and the team’s offensive unit, despite their 8-8 record and absence from the playoffs. With significant offseason decisions ahead, McCarthy’s development will be at the forefront as Minnesota looks to build towards future success.