The Minnesota Vikings kicked off the 2025 season with great aspirations following a strong 2024 performance, during which they achieved 14 victories under former quarterback Sam Darnold, who has since moved on to the Seattle Seahawks for Super Bowl LX. In an unexpected turn, the Vikings opted not to retain Darnold, leading head coach Kevin O’Connell to place his trust in J.J. McCarthy, the team’s first-round pick from 2023. Unfortunately, the results have not met expectations.
McCarthy struggled during his first full season, starting only 10 games due to injuries and finishing with 1,632 passing yards, 11 touchdowns, and a troubling 12 interceptions. Although O’Connell is likely to give McCarthy another shot in 2026, the need for competition has become apparent, especially with last year’s backup, Carson Wentz, now a free agent and recovering from his own injury.
To fortify their quarterback roster and challenge McCarthy for the starting role, the Vikings could consider several key players:
1. **Malik Willis**: The former Tennessee Titan demonstrated considerable skill in his short stint with the Green Bay Packers, racking up 422 passing yards, 123 rushing yards, five touchdowns, and just one turnover during four games as a starter. His blend of athleticism and improved decision-making puts him in a position to create healthy competition for McCarthy. However, financial constraints may limit Minnesota’s ability to sign him.
2. **Mac Jones**: Successfully stepping in for an injured Brock Purdy with the San Francisco 49ers, Jones led the team to a 5-3 record in eight starts, passing for 2,151 yards and 13 touchdowns against six interceptions. With a year left on his contract, securing Jones would require creative maneuvering from the Vikings, but the potential rewards are significant.
3. **Russell Wilson**: As a veteran presence, Wilson could bring invaluable mentorship to McCarthy, despite a lackluster performance during his last season with the New York Giants. Even as he plans to return to play in 2026, Wilson’s experience could provide the push McCarthy needs while ensuring the team has a reliable backup should challenges arise.
McCarthy’s developed competition is essential for his progress as a quarterback. Injuries to both him and Wentz have hindered that growth, making it imperative for O’Connell to find a competitor who can truly challenge McCarthy for the starting position. The Vikings must act decisively to seek a capable quarterback who can not only support McCarthy but also step into a leadership role if needed, ensuring Minnesota remains competitive in the tough landscape of the NFL. With strategic acquisitions, the Vikings can reinforce their outlook for the upcoming season, potentially setting the stage for renewed success.