One of college football’s most enduring rivalries is set to take a significant pause starting in 2026. After extensive discussions, the University of Southern California (USC) and the University of Notre Dame have failed to reach an agreement to continue their long-standing series, known for its thrilling matchups and rich history.
In a joint statement released by both institutions, they acknowledged the significance of their rivalry, expressing a mutual commitment to reviving “The Battle for the Jeweled Shillelagh” in the future. The statement noted, “The rivalry between our two schools is one of the best in all of sport, and we look forward to meeting again in the future.”
Discussions broke down following the announcement of the College Football Playoff (CFP) field, as a source familiar with the negotiations revealed that Notre Dame had secured an agreement with CFP officials that guarantees them a playoff berth if they are ranked among the top 12 at season’s end, effective 2026. This agreement was perceived by USC officials as a significant advantage for the Irish, heightening tensions as both sides attempted to navigate the complexities of their scheduling needs.
Previously, the schools were close to an agreement, with a compromise proposed that would have allowed Notre Dame to visit the Coliseum in 2026 while preserving the tradition of the rivalry. However, once USC learned of Notre Dame’s negotiations with the CFP, their athletic director Jennifer Cohen decided against proceeding with any compromises, insisting instead that the game could only occur in Week Zero or not at all. This ultimatum was ultimately rejected by Notre Dame’s athletic director Pete Bevacqua.
With the suspension of the rivalry, the earliest possible return to the field could be as late as 2030, allowing for a five-year hiatus from a competition that has been historically significant, having only paused during World War II and the pandemic. Before this, the two teams faced off for 78 consecutive seasons, with their most recent clash resulting in a 34-24 victory for Notre Dame in October.
As USC looks to adapt, they are actively seeking to fill their 2026 schedule with an alternative nonconference opponent, ideally one from the former Pac-12, such as Stanford or California. However, finding flexibility in their schedules from those institutions might prove challenging. USC is evaluating options that might include teams with unique circumstances, such as those playing at Hawaii or internationally, which are permitted to have a 13th game due to travel-related allowances.
Notre Dame has already moved to secure a new rival, announcing a multi-year agreement with Brigham Young University to fill the gap left by the Trojans.
Criticism has arisen from former players like Trojans’ legend Keyshawn Johnson, who expressed disbelief at the situation and questioned the leadership within USC’s athletic department, suggesting a disconnect between decision-makers and the college’s storied traditions.
Despite the current setback, both sides have expressed hope for a future matchup. The commitment to preserving the spirit of this rivalry remains, and fans can look forward to a potential return to the gridiron, maintaining their enthusiasm for one of college football’s historic contests. As the landscape of college sports continues to evolve, there remains an optimistic outlook for the resumption of this cherished rivalry in years to come.