The new Netflix series “American Primeval” portrays a brutal vision of Utah in 1857, delving into the darker aspects of life during that era. Created by Pete Berg and written by Mark L. Smith, known for “The Revenant,” the series paints a grisly picture of a lawless world rife with greed, tribalism, violence, and racism. The production may leave viewers feeling more disturbed than entertained, as it offers a pointed critique on humanity’s most depraved qualities.
Focusing on Sara Rowell, played by Betty Gilpin, the story tracks her harrowing journey westward with her young son, Devin. As they navigate a brutal landscape, they encounter an array of characters and conflicts, including the tensions between Indigenous nations, the U.S. government, and the Mormon community led by Brigham Young. The ensemble cast also showcases Taylor Kitsch as Isaac, a rugged character with ties to the Shoshone tribe, while Dane DeHaan provides a haunting performance as a man bent on finding his missing wife through increasingly dark means.
While the series struggles at times under the weight of its multiple plotlines and can become overly grim, its strong performances stand out amid the chaos. Critics note that the level of violence and graphic imagery could detract from the story’s substance, but it does manage to capture a raw historical lesson about America’s past.
“American Primeval” challenges the romanticized narratives often associated with the Western genre, instead offering a reflection of humanity’s capacity for darkness. Despite its flaws, the series presents strong performances, particularly from Gilpin and DeHaan, which could resonate with audiences searching for depth amidst the turmoil.
In a broader context, “American Primeval” encourages conversations about historical truth in storytelling. As it pushes boundaries, it remains a thought-provoking piece that may appeal to viewers interested in the complexities of human nature amidst historical struggles. While the series might not be for everyone, those who appreciate gritty narratives may find its exploration of the human condition compelling.
Summary: Netflix’s “American Primeval” presents a stark and brutal portrayal of 1857 Utah, focusing on the dark aspects of human nature amidst conflicts between tribes, settlers, and Mormons. While it features strong performances, particularly by Betty Gilpin and Dane DeHaan, the series struggles with its heavy violence and convoluted plotlines. Nonetheless, it serves as a poignant commentary on America’s historical struggles and the complexities of human morality.