The trial of Daniel Penny, accused of fatally choking Jordan Neely last year on a New York City subway, has seen a significant development. A judge has dismissed a manslaughter charge after the jury reported being deadlocked, allowing them to focus solely on the lesser charge of criminally negligent homicide, which carries a maximum sentence of four years. Penny has pleaded not guilty to the charges.
During deliberations, the jury, which consists of seven women and five men, indicated their struggle to reach a unanimous decision on the manslaughter charge. Following their initial note, Judge Maxwell Wiley encouraged them to keep an open mind and continue deliberating. After hearing from jurors that they remained undecided, the judge informed them they could now consider the lesser charge.
The incident in question occurred on May 1, 2023, when Penny, a former Marine and architecture student, confronted Neely, a homeless man suffering from mental illness. Witnesses noted that Neely displayed erratic behavior before Penny placed him in a chokehold for approximately six minutes. Tragically, Neely was found to have died from compression to his neck due to the hold, a conclusion the defense disputes.
The case has sparked broader discussions on issues of racial justice, homelessness, and mental health in New York City. Penny’s legal team argues that he acted out of concern for the safety of fellow passengers and did not intend to harm Neely.
Throughout the trial, jurors have actively sought clarification on various definitions related to the charges, indicating they are taking their responsibilities seriously. Judge Wiley expressed confidence in their conscientiousness and urged them to strive for a just verdict, emphasizing the complexity of their task.
As the jury resumes deliberations on Monday, there remains hope that members will find clarity in their discussions and reach a resolution that reflects the fairness of the judicial process.
This case highlights the ongoing societal challenges surrounding mental health and public safety, illustrating the need for continued dialogue and solutions in addressing these critical issues.