The conclusion of Season 2 of “Tell Me Lies” leaves viewers questioning the growth of Stephen and Lucy, as they appear to have worsened in their toxic relationship. The Hulu series, based on Carola Lovering’s novel, continues to explore their complicated bond, which spans from their college years in 2008 to a friend’s wedding in 2015.
Executive producer and showrunner Meaghan Oppenheimer expressed hopes that the series could help viewers identify toxic behaviors in relationships. While she believes that Stephen’s character isn’t entirely devoid of love, his actions often come across as chilling and hurtful, as described by actor Jackson White, who portrays him. This season, Stephen struggles with his identity as a “bad person” and forms a connection with Lucy, who accepts his flaws.
The season finale, which aired on October 16, featured a series of dramatic events, including weddings, deaths, and tumultuous relationships. A significant plot twist involves Wrigley reconciling with his brother Drew, who tragically dies from a drug overdose after celebrating their reunion. Stephen ultimately takes the blame for an anonymous letter Lucy wrote about Drew’s involvement in a fatal car accident, which leads to Wrigley forgiving him.
Additionally, Bree discovers the truth about her involvement with her professor’s husband, Oliver, only to find out that his wife is aware of their relationship, leaving Bree feeling manipulated and betrayed. Meanwhile, Lucy’s romantic entanglements create a love triangle involving Stephen and her ex, Leo, escalating tension between the characters.
At the wedding, betrayal takes center stage when Bree learns of Evan’s past infidelity with Lucy right as she is about to walk down the aisle. Oppenheimer notes that Stephen’s quest for revenge is a driving force behind his actions, leading to climactic moments that leave viewers on edge and questioning the characters’ futures. The season ends with Lucy and Bree facing the repercussions of their choices, suggesting that unresolved tensions may carry into a potential third season.