As the 2025 Footballguys Roundtable draws to a close, our distinguished panel of fantasy experts has been intensely dissecting the standout rookies from this year’s class and their potential value heading into the 2026 season. In the latest roundtable discussion, panelists shared their rankings and insights on the top five rookies poised to excel in fantasy leagues.
Joseph Haggan kicked off the conversation by highlighting Ashton Jeanty as a top contender, crediting him for his impressive performance through the season. Jeanty, who has emerged as a workhorse for the struggling Raiders, is expected to see substantial volume next year, solidifying his value. He was joined on the list by Jaxson Dart, who has shown promise in the quarterback position, especially with his rushing ability—a key factor for fantasy managers. Emeka Egbuka also made the cut, having stepped up significantly after injuries hampered the receiving corps early in the season, showcasing skills that could guarantee him a key role moving forward.
Tyler Warren’s name came up as another promising talent, having demonstrated versatility in his play style, making him a player to watch if the Colts can stabilize their quarterback situation. Additionally, RJ Harvey’s capability as a workhorse running back presents a bright future for next season, given his impressive performances post-JK Dobbins’ injury.
Tipp Major contributed to the list with his own picks, featuring players like Luther Burden III, who has been showing flashes of brilliance reminiscent of Amon-Ra St. Brown. Burden’s potential for growth in an offense he believes could reach top-five status by 2026 is notable. Tetairoa McMillan also stood out, being just shy of 1,000 receiving yards this season, while Harold Fannin Jr. is seen as a reliable prospect due to his connection with Matthew Stafford.
David Zacharias reiterated the strong performances of Jeanty and McMillan, while also mentioning Omarion Hampton, who though limited in games, left a mark on the Chargers’ offense. He emphasized Fannin’s standout rookie season among tight ends and Tyler Warren’s consistent contributions, determining their potential for the 2026 season.
Will Grant rounded out the conversation, confirming Jeanty’s potential while also highlighting Egbuka’s rapid ascent in the Buccaneers’ offense. He expressed excitement for Dart’s growth if the Giants can provide him with better offensive support, and made a case for Colston Loveland, who is likely to emerge as a top-10 fantasy tight end after a slow start to his season.
This deep dive into the rookie class showcases the wealth of young talent that could significantly impact fantasy leagues moving forward. The analysts’ insights suggest that as these players continue to develop, many could become cornerstone figures on fantasy rosters, bringing a hopeful outlook for managers preparing for next season.