The world of theater often presents challenges, particularly when it comes to one-person shows, which can leave audiences grappling with monotonous narratives about addiction, abuse, or identity crises. However, “The Unknown,” making its world premiere at Off-Broadway’s Studio Seaview, breaks this mold with an engaging and thrilling solo performance from Sean Hayes.
Written by David Cale, this captivating drama is less a confessional piece and more a haunting exploration of identity and reality. Hayes plays Elliott, a playwright and composer, who embarks on a retreat to a remote house in upstate New York, invited by friends Larry and Chloe. With no internet or phone service, the secluded setting serves as an unnerving backdrop for Elliott’s creative struggle, amplifying the tension as strange occurrences begin to unfold.
On his first night, Elliott hears a male voice singing outside, performing his own song titled “I Wish You’d Wanted Me,” a detail that hints at the deeper mysteries to come. The plot thickens as Elliott finds himself caught in a web of stalking, poor decisions, and encounters that blur the line between reality and perception. Throughout this chilling odyssey, Elliott maintains a sense of humor, adding depth and layers to the drama.
Sean Hayes, fresh from his acclaimed role as Oscar Levant in “Good Night, Oscar,” delivers an exceptional performance, seamlessly transitioning between multiple characters with a natural charm that captivates the audience. His ability to hold attention during the play’s uninterrupted 80 minutes underscores his skill as a performer and enhances the storytelling.
Director Leigh Silverman’s expert staging creates an atmospheric experience, complemented by Cha See’s ominous lighting and Caroline Eng’s unsettling sound effects, along with Isobel Waller-Bridge’s tense musical score. The combination of these elements immerses the audience in the unsettling world Elliott navigates.
While some narrative aspects may not fully resonate, “The Unknown” offers a thought-provoking examination of identity and reality that keeps viewers engaged from start to finish. The production opened on February 12, 2025, at Studio Seaview and is set to run until April 12. Tickets for this intriguing performance can be found at studioseaview.com.