Hallmark movies often transport viewers to a quirky universe that resembles our own yet operates under its own unique rules. The latest addition to their holiday lineup, “The Christmas Baby,” exemplifies this whimsical setting while also incorporating familiar real-life locations in Upstate New York, including Schenectady, Saratoga, and Albany. However, the depiction of Albany in the film contrasts sharply with its true winter reality, which is generally marked by the slush and biting winds of December, rather than the charmingly pristine conditions showcased in the movie.
Starring Ali Liebert and Katherine Barrell, “The Christmas Baby” follows a married couple, Erin and Kelly, who find an abandoned baby named Nicholas, accompanied by a heartfelt note requesting their care. While the premise is undeniably heartwarming, the film approaches serious themes of parenthood and the unexpected changes it brings to a couple’s lives with lighthearted charm. Erin runs a gift-wrapping and shipping business, while Kelly is involved in community design; both characters face the dilemma of their burgeoning responsibilities as potential parents amid their busy lives.
The film briefly touches upon societal issues, hinting at the existence of civil rights struggles for LGBTQ+ couples, but ultimately maintains a gentle focus on the characters’ inner journey and their evolving love for the baby. Hallmark has been gradually increasing its representation of same-sex relationships in recent years, and “The Christmas Baby,” while sweet and tenderhearted, feels like a cautious step forward in this regard.
While the film checks many boxes for a classic Hallmark holiday story—complete with festive cheer and adorable infant casting—it does fall short of capturing the true complexities of parenting and baby care. Aspects of reality, such as teething milestones and safe sleeping practices, are sometimes overlooked, which is a common critique of films across all genres.
Despite these discrepancies, “The Christmas Baby” aims to leave audiences with a feel-good sentiment, emphasizing love, family, and the joy of unexpected surprises during the holiday season. As Hallmark continues to evolve and include more diverse narratives, fans can look forward to a heartwarming holiday experience that promotes love in all its forms.