The jury foreperson in the retrial of Harvey Weinstein voiced concerns on Monday about divisive discussions among jurors, suggesting some were attempting to sway others by referencing Weinstein’s past. In a private conversation with Judge Curtis Farber, the foreperson expressed discomfort with jurors discussing aspects of Weinstein’s history unrelated to the specific charges at hand.
The foreperson stated, “I feel like they are attacking, talking together, fight together. I don’t like it.” He emphasized that the jury should focus solely on the evidence related to the allegations, rather than Weinstein’s past actions. Defense attorney Arthur Aidala seized on these remarks to call for a mistrial, labeling the jury’s conduct as “tainted” and pointing out that deliberations should remain grounded in the evidence presented during the trial.
Prosecutor Matthew Colangelo countered by noting that some of Weinstein’s past was admissible evidence, particularly relating to other accusations against him. Judge Farber ultimately denied the mistrial request but reminded jurors to focus on evidence from the trial itself.
Throughout the deliberation process, which began last Thursday, it has been reported that tensions have flared, as some jurors have faced difficulties. However, after the foreperson’s remarks, another juror stepped forward to temper the situation, indicating that progress was being made and asserting that the group’s tone had improved.
Weinstein, who is 73 years old and has maintained his innocence, faces charges that include two counts of committing a criminal sex act and one count of rape. This retrial follows a previous conviction in 2020, which was overturned, and a pending appeal regarding a separate rape conviction in Los Angeles.
As deliberations persist, jurors have requested to revisit specific testimonies and have indicated they are making strides toward a consensus. While the journey has faced challenges, the dialogue among jurors suggests progress is being made in their discussions and decision-making.