The second season of Tell Me Lies, which aired its finale on October 16, 2024, has left fans eager for more. Adapted from Carola Lovering’s novel, the Hulu drama explores the tumultuous and toxic relationship between Lucy Albright (played by Grace Van Patten) and Stephen DeMarco (portrayed by Jackson White), who first connected during Lucy’s freshman year at the fictional Baird College. Their relationship becomes increasingly complicated, marked by infidelity and emotional turmoil.
The season finale wrapped up with a dramatic climax, hinting that a potential third season would delve into a decade-long revenge plot. Fans remain hopeful for news regarding Tell Me Lies’ future, as discussions on social media continue to thrive, keeping the series in Hulu’s Top 15 in the U.S. throughout the airing of season 2. The renewal for season 2 was announced just a month after the premiere of season 1, leading to speculation that good news may arrive soon.
If a renewal is confirmed, viewers might face a lengthy wait for new episodes. Season 2 was released in September 2024, two years following the first season’s debut in October 2022. If the pattern continues, fans can expect season 3 to possibly air in fall 2026.
Fans can anticipate the return of main characters, ensuring that Grace Van Patten and Jackson White will reprise their roles as Lucy and Stephen. Other cast members likely to return include Catherine Missal (Bree), Spencer House (Wrigley), Sonia Mena (Pippa), Branden Cook (Evan), Alicia Crowder (Diana), and Natalee Linez (Lydia). However, Tom Ellis, who played Oliver, is not expected to return, having initially signed on for just one season. There are hints that Gabriella Pession’s character, Marianne, will be back in the next season.
The season 2 finale leaves many plotlines unresolved, particularly relating to Stephen and Lucy’s fraught relationship. Key questions include Stephen’s engagement to Lydia, the consequences of Bree and Oliver’s affair, Pippa’s pursuit of justice for her assault, and the mystery surrounding Stephen’s role in Macy’s death. The series has notably diverged from its source material, with expanding character arcs and storylines.
Creator Meaghan Oppenheimer indicated in interviews that season 3 might include a time jump, potentially focusing more on the events of 2015 rather than the original college timeline. There is considerable curiosity about how the characters’ lives will evolve.
Reflecting on the finale, Van Patten expressed astonishment at Stephen’s long-held secret about Evan’s betrayal, highlighting the psychological manipulation involved. White also shared his thoughts, suggesting that Stephen might find himself trapped without any escape routes in future episodes, teasing intriguing possibilities for the show’s direction.