In a recent decision, the South Carolina state parole board denied Susan Smith’s request for parole. Smith, who infamously murdered her two young sons, Michael and Alex, three decades ago, was seeking to be released after serving 30 years of her life sentence.
The tragic events unfolded on October 25, 1994, when Smith rolled her car, with her sons strapped in their seats, into John D. Long Lake in Union County. Smith initially misled the public by claiming that a Black man had carjacked her and taken her children. It was not until nine days later that she confessed to the crime.
During the parole hearing, Smith expressed deep remorse for her actions, stating, “I just want to say how very sorry I am.” Her lawyer, Tommy Thomas, introduced arguments related to her mental health history, mentioning her struggles with depression that began in childhood. He detailed how Smith is pursuing a counseling degree and has support systems in place if released.
However, 15 individuals, including her ex-husband David Smith and local political figures, spoke out against her release, emphasizing that her actions were premeditated rather than a tragic mistake. They highlighted the profound betrayal felt by the community and the deep impact of her actions. David Smith poignantly noted, “She made a free choice that night to end their life.”
The board’s decision to deny Smith parole was unanimous, with one member recusing herself. This reflects the serious nature of her crime, the psychological impact on the victims’ family, and the community’s overwhelming opposition to her release.
Smith has a history of disciplinary issues while incarcerated, including a recent incident involving unauthorized communication with a filmmaker. This has further raised doubts about her trustworthiness if released.
Despite the grim nature of this case, it serves as a reminder of the importance of mental health awareness and support. The focus on Smith’s psychological struggles illustrates the complex interplay between mental health and crime. Additionally, the resilience shown by David Smith, who has rebuilt his life and remains an advocate for his children’s memory, offers a glimmer of hope amidst tragedy.
Smith is next eligible for parole in 2026, giving the community time to continue voicing opposition and highlighting the need for justice for Michael and Alex.