The debate among DC fans over the merits of James Gunn’s DC Universe (DCU) versus Zack Snyder’s DC Extended Universe (DCEU) has intensified, specifically regarding a hypothetical matchup between the new Superman, portrayed by David Corenswet, and Henry Cavill’s iconic Man of Steel. The discussions have become increasingly animated on social media platforms, primarily Twitter.
Since the announcement of the new Superman film, fans have voiced their opinions passionately. While some Cavill supporters were disappointed that he was not recast in the role, many fans of Corenswet were excited about a fresh take on the beloved superhero. The online discourse has seen notable exchanges, such as one user claiming, “Cavill’s Superman would wipe the floor with Corenswet’s Superman,” which ignited a flurry of responses from both sides.
Supporters of Corenswet emphasized his character’s incredible feats, including a scenario where he escapes a black hole while aiding three individuals using his super breath. In defense of Cavill’s Superman, fans argued that he similarly displayed extraordinary strength by breaking free from the Phantom Zone, which functions like a black hole.
The conversation also turned to whether Corenswet’s version would stand a chance against Ben Affleck’s Batman, who notably triumphed over Cavill’s Superman. Some fans suggested that if Batman could nearly defeat Cavill, he would easily overcome Corenswet’s Superman. However, others pointed out that this new Superman’s narrative arc begins with a defeat, casting him in a comparatively vulnerable position against formidable adversaries like Lex Luthor.
Amid the fan rivalry, a voice of reason emerged, reminding others that both characters are fundamentally good and would likely not engage in a fight against each other. This sentiment reflects a broader understanding among some fans, promoting respect for both portrayals of the iconic hero.
Interestingly, both Gunn and Snyder have taken this rivalry in stride. They recently appeared in an episode of Rick and Morty as parodied versions of themselves, humorously bickering over who created the better depiction of Superman.
As audiences enjoy the new Superman film in theaters, discussions around the future of DC movies continue, with fans looking forward to exploring the legacy of these beloved characters further.