PITTSBURGH — The future of the Pittsburgh Steelers’ quarterback position can be traced back to before the current season. On August 28, head coach Mike Tomlin announced that Russell Wilson would be the team’s starting quarterback, while also emphasizing the importance of giving Justin Fields opportunities in specific packages that highlight his impressive mobility.
This context is especially relevant following Tomlin’s recent statement that Wilson will be “in contention” to play and possibly start in the upcoming Sunday night game against the New York Jets. Some have interpreted this as a signal that Fields may be benched, but this situation may not be as straightforward as it seems.
Fields has the potential to earn back the starting role, whether it be this week or later in the season. As long as Tomlin adheres to his initial plan from six weeks ago, the answer to the quarterback dilemma might involve both players rather than one being cast aside.
When asked about what Fields needs to improve on to keep his starting position after going 4-2, Tomlin remarked, “Justin has been really good. We’ve been really good at times — but not to be confused as great. This is a competitive league. We’re trying to position ourselves to be that team.”
If Tomlin expects exceptional quarterback play, then Wilson must also meet those expectations. There’s no certainty that he will significantly outperform Fields after two challenging seasons in Denver. Wilson will need to demonstrate his skills, especially in passing and leading the offense, all while knowing that Fields has valuable first-team experience waiting for another chance.
The competition for the starting role may still be ongoing. For the first time since offseason activities, Wilson is slated to get substantial playing time with the first-team offense. Additionally, offensive coordinator Arthur Smith has praised Fields and has effectively utilized his talents on the field.
Managing this unique situation will be crucial for the Steelers as they strive for a playoff spot and an end to their postseason win drought, which has lasted since 2016. The strategy will depend on maximizing each player’s strengths to revive an offense that has lacked consistency.
Wilson, in his 13th season, brings a wealth of experience as a quarterback, but at nearly 36 years old, he lacks the mobility of his earlier years, particularly as he recovers from a calf injury. He has been sacked more than any other player in the league twice over the past five seasons, and with the Steelers’ struggling offensive line, the risk of him getting sacked is significant.
Despite these concerns, Wilson’s arm strength remains an asset, allowing him to make deep throws that can elevate the offense. The Steelers aim to establish a run-heavy game, giving Wilson opportunities to connect on deep play-action passes.
While Wilson is a more accurate passer—an important quality for a receiving corps that struggles with separation—it’s worth noting that Fields is also a dynamic offensive weapon. His speed and elusiveness are invaluable in the red zone, and his ability to scramble has mitigated many potential sacks. The coaching staff continues to incorporate new strategies to leverage Fields’ running capabilities, which may not be as prominent if Wilson starts.
If Wilson takes over, there is still a way to utilize Fields creatively in the running game. Tomlin has not disclosed how practice reps will be divided between the quarterbacks or when he will announce a starter, stating that “It remains to be seen,” and adding that the ongoing discussion is intriguing.
The ideal scenario for the Steelers would be if Wilson effectively manages the game while bringing a necessary aerial threat. If Fields receives enough playtime, he could remain an explosive option in the running game, creating a dual-threat dynamic.
This scenario doesn’t eliminate the possibility of Fields, like Wilson, becoming the long-term starter, especially since Tomlin had hoped that Fields would benefit from Wilson’s experience early this season. If the Steelers keep Fields engaged, there is still a chance for him to establish himself as the primary quarterback for the next season.
It’s also plausible that if the offense falters with Wilson under center, the Steelers could adjust during the game, integrating more of Fields’ skill set if needed. Tomlin could creatively use Fields without officially naming him the starter or sidelining Wilson.
The situation is likely to develop as the season progresses, but currently, all possibilities remain open, and this won’t be the last time we hear from Fields.