Saiyaara, featuring Ahaan Panday and Aneet Padda, made its debut in theaters on July 18, achieving a notable box office collection of Rs 21 crore on its opening day. Directed by Mohit Suri, the film has been well-received for its music and performances, but it has also sparked a debate online regarding its storyline.
Many viewers have drawn comparisons between Saiyaara and the 2004 South Korean film A Moment To Remember, directed by John H. Lee. Both films center around a romantic relationship that faces challenges when the female lead is diagnosed with early-onset Alzheimer’s disease. In Saiyaara, Krish Kapur, portrayed by Ahaan Panday, is a hot-headed musician, and Vaani, played by Aneet Padda, is a reserved journalist. As Vaani’s condition deteriorates, the couple’s love and commitment are put to the ultimate test.
Social media users have pointed out striking similarities between the two narratives. Comments highlight recurring themes, such as the emotional struggles linked to Alzheimer’s, and even specific plot points that mirror each other, including a pivotal moment where the male protagonist attempts to recreate cherished memories.
Despite claims of imitation, some audience members have come to the film’s defense. They argue that adapting a familiar narrative can be done with a unique touch. As one social media user noted, the trend of using disease-related storylines as a means to evoke emotional connections in romantic tales is not new and can resonate well if executed thoughtfully.
As of now, the film’s creators have not confirmed whether Saiyaara is officially based on A Moment To Remember.
Written by Sankalp Sadanah and featuring dialogues by Rohan Shankar, the film also boasts a diverse music score from several artists, including Mithoon and Tanishk Bagchi. Produced by Yash Raj Films’ CEO Akshaye Widhani, Saiyaara continues to attract attention and provoke discussions about its thematic inspirations.
This discourse not only highlights the cultural exchange between cinema industries but also illustrates how classic narratives can be rejuvenated to resonate with modern audiences. The conversation surrounding adapted stories can often lead viewers to appreciate different interpretations while celebrating the art of filmmaking.