In the recently released film “Saipan,” viewers are presented with a dramatized retelling of the infamous pre-2002 World Cup training camp that led to Roy Keane’s controversial departure from the Irish national team. Éanna Hardwicke portrays Keane during a rare quiet moment by the pool, an intriguing contrast to the chaotic environment surrounding the squad.
The film includes a humorous exchange between Keane and Millwall midfielder Steven Reid, showcasing a lighter side of the often-serious footballer. It is a moment that draws laughs from audiences and evokes memories for those who played alongside Keane, such as his former teammate Tony Cascarino. Cascarino recalls a time when Keane made it clear that there were “no mates” in football, despite shared battles on the pitch.
“Saipan” explores the historical friction between Keane and manager Mick McCarthy during this tumultuous period, but tends to exaggerate the dynamics between the two. While Keane is portrayed as an unwavering professional, the depiction of McCarthy, played by Steve Coogan, lacks depth. Sources suggest that McCarthy’s character is more complex than shown, with friends from that era recalling tough confrontations that were omitted from the film, such as McCarthy’s resolute stance during their showdown.
Moreover, the film hints at a light-hearted trip for the team, yet those who experienced it note how tightly controlled the schedule was, contrasting with the more relaxed atmosphere of previous World Cups. Despite their departure, the Irish team performed commendably in the tournament, achieving a draw against World Cup finalists Germany and reaching the knockout stage before being eliminated.
Cascarino mentions a striking point regarding the post-World Cup perception of the team: the saga with Keane often overshadows their accomplishments. The film does not fully convey the achievements of that squad in 2002, which included significant games that did not involve Keane.
Interestingly, the halcyon days of Jack Charlton’s management saw a different camaraderie and freedom for players, with nights out included as a part of maintaining team morale. In McCarthy’s tenure, following Charlton’s legacy, there was an effort to balance the players’ social lives with discipline, resulting in more structured team dynamics.
The film has generated mixed reactions among former teammates, with many showing little interest in revisiting the narrative. The iconic stories, controversies, and memorable matches have simmered into a feeling of embarrassment among some who wish to focus on the team’s achievements rather than past disagreements.
In retrospect, as was seen when Mick McCarthy returned to manage the team again years later, there remains a perspective that historic events do not singularly define either man’s professional merits. The story of Saipan stands as a poignant reminder of the complexities within a sport characterized by both fierce competition and the deep bonds formed among players.