Governor Josh Shapiro is a skilled politician who could have been a strong vice presidential candidate, and there’s still a chance he might be considered for that role in the future. Yet, many are feeling a sense of relief regarding his potential candidacy. The excitement over a prominent Jewish figure entering national politics comes with apprehension, particularly about the anticipated rise in antisemitism and the divisive scrutiny from both the Right and the Left.
This sentiment is shared among others, including Rabbi Rachel Barenblat, who expressed relief about avoiding the heightened antisemitism that a Shapiro candidacy might incite. American Jews should not have to worry in 2024 about a Jewish vice-presidential nominee sparking an increase in hatred and prejudice. The memories of Senator Joe Lieberman’s candidacy in 2000 felt less contentious in comparison.
Today, the atmosphere is marked by Christian Nationalist antisemitism on the Right and anti-Zionist antisemitism on the Left, with both tensions already evident in response to Shapiro’s possible nomination. The increasing threat to Jewish safety stems largely from white supremacist groups and inflammatory rhetoric from prominent figures, including former President Donald Trump, who has made derogatory comments about Jewish individuals who align with Democrats.
The anticipation of defending Jewish identity and liberal-Zionist positions during a campaign does not bring joy. While mainstream Democrats would likely support Vice President Kamala Harris over Shapiro’s critics, the hard-left minority distorts his record, calling him derogatory names and misrepresenting his stance on key issues regarding Israel and Palestine.
Despite some statements from Shapiro being seen as inflammatory, the extreme left’s mischaracterization of his policies is troubling. Shapiro’s political views align with many American Jews who advocate for a Jewish state while questioning its current policies and calling for peace initiatives.
Interestingly, the criticisms leveled at Shapiro are more intense than those faced by his non-Jewish counterparts with similar stances, raising questions about the motivations behind such scrutiny. While criticism of Israel need not be antisemitic, holding Jewish candidates to different standards certainly is.
Ultimately, there is a bittersweet feeling accompanying this relief. Shapiro embodies an ideal for many, showcasing the integration of Jewish identity with progressive values, and serving as a role model for future generations. Nevertheless, the issues surrounding his candidacy would have distracted from the critical fight against rising authoritarianism in America. A hopeful vision is one where Jewish politicians can run for office free from fear of prejudice, allowing communities to unite in support without hesitation.