Rachel Brosnahan will headline and executive‑produce Season 2 of Presumed Innocent on Apple TV+, as the show continues its anthology format with a new lead and case.
Season 1, which premiered in 2024, was based on Scott Turow’s novel and followed a prosecutor who is accused of killing a colleague. Apple TV+ has opted to shift away from a single continuing character, keeping Gyllenhaal involved as an executive producer for Season 2 while presenting a new storyline and protagonist.
Season 2 will adapt Jo Murray’s upcoming book Dissection of a Murder, slated for publication in 2026. While Apple has not released an official logline, the publisher Pan Macmillan describes the central case this way: Leila Reynolds, played by Brosnahan, is handed her first murder assignment and is confronted with a high-profile case—the murder of a well‑known judge. The defendant, Jack Millman, is said to want her, and her alone, a scenario that tests her boundaries and expertise.
The project is developed by David E. Kelley, who will serve as executive producer and co‑showrunner, with Erica Lipez joining as co‑showrunner and executive producer for Season 2. Bad Robot Productions is also involved, with J.J. Abrams and Rachel Rusch Rich executive producing.
Brosnahan’s return to a leading TV role marks her first since The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel concluded, a series for which she earned multiple Emmy nominations and Golden Globes. She is also set to appear as Lois Lane in James Gunn’s upcoming Superman film.
What this signals for fans: Apple TV+ is doubling down on high-caliber, character-driven legal drama within an anthology framework, backed by a team with strong track records in both television and film.
Key facts:
– Rachel Brosnahan will star in and executive‑produce Season 2
– Season 2 is based on Jo Murray’s Dissection of a Murder (book due 2026)
– Leila Reynolds is the new lead; the case involves a high-profile judge’s murder
– Jake Gyllenhaal remains an executive producer for Season 2, but not the lead
– David E. Kelley is the showrunner; Erica Lipez is co‑showrunner; Bad Robot’s J.J. Abrams and Rachel Rusch Rich are executive producers
– Brosnahan’s return to TV follows The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel; she will also appear in the upcoming Superman film as Lois Lane
This development offers a hopeful path for fans who enjoy gripping legal thrillers with fresh perspectives, strong performances, and ambitious storytelling. If you’d like, I can add a concise synopsis teaser or a quick fan-forward preview based on the book’s themes.