Attorneys for BYU quarterback Jake Retzlaff have formally responded to a civil lawsuit filed against him, alleging sexual assault against a woman from Salt Lake County in November 2023. In the court response, Retzlaff, through his attorney Stephen R. Waldron, categorically denies all allegations, describing them as “ridiculous and bizarre.”
The lawsuit, filed on May 21, claims that Retzlaff bit, raped, and strangled the plaintiff, referred to as Jane Doe A.G., during a supposed encounter in his Provo apartment after a night of video games with friends. The suit seeks over $300,000 in damages across three claims. In contrast, Retzlaff asserts that their interaction was consensual, characterized as a pleasant evening with no uncomfortable incidents reported during or afterwards.
In support of his defense, the response highlights a history of friendly communication post-incident, including text messages exchanged between Retzlaff and the plaintiff, which the attorneys claim demonstrate a lack of discontent regarding their encounter. Notably, these messages featured playful banter about sports, including their teams’ rivalry, suggesting that A.G. was engaged and upbeat.
BYU has acknowledged the lawsuit but maintains a policy of not commenting further on ongoing legal matters due to privacy laws. The university’s Honor Code explicitly prohibits premarital sexual relations, adding another layer of complexity to the case as it unfolds.
With Retzlaff continuing to practice with his team and affirming his innocence, this case remains under scrutiny. It highlights the challenges student-athletes face amid serious allegations and the legal ramifications that can arise from personal interactions.
This situation serves as a reminder of the importance of clear communication and consent in all relationships, especially in high-profile environments such as college athletics. As both sides prepare for potential trial proceedings, the case will likely be watched closely by fans and the wider community.