The Philadelphia Phillies are poised for a crucial offseason, as the team considers significant decisions regarding key players such as Kyle Schwarber and JT Realmuto, alongside potential internal trades and adjustments. As part of this critical period, the fate of several notable prospects, including Andrew Painter, Aidan Miller, and Justin Crawford, is drawing attention.
MLB.com insider Johnathan Mayo has insight into the Phillies’ strategy concerning their top prospects. Despite the team’s need to strengthen its roster, Mayo indicated that he would be surprised if the Phillies decided to trade any of their top three prospects this winter. Painter, Miller, and Crawford represent Philadelphia’s premier young talent, and there is considerable investment in their development.
The front office demonstrated its commitment to Painter during last season’s trade negotiations when the team was approached by the Minnesota Twins about a deal involving the promising prospect. The Phillies maintained their stance, firmly rejecting requests to part ways with Painter, choosing instead to trade away other top-10 prospects like Mick Abel and Eduardo Tait.
Looking ahead, unless an exceptional player becomes available who could provide long-term value, it appears unlikely that the Phillies will move on from Miller, Painter, or Crawford. Crawford, in particular, has a strong chance of making the Opening Day roster as the Phillies seek to bolster their outfield, potentially stepping into a starting role by 2026. Painter might also find a spot in the rotation, contingent on a strong showing in Spring Training, though his entry into the rotation may occur later in 2026.
Meanwhile, Miller, who recently progressed to Triple-A, faces uncertainty in his path to joining the Major League roster due to Trea Turner solidifying the shortstop position. His future could see him sliding into third or second base, but chances are he may remain in the minors for an additional year.
Overall, the outlook for Andrew Painter, Aidan Miller, and Justin Crawford remains bright. While the Phillies tackle their offseason objectives, their commitment to nurturing these young prospects suggests a hopeful future for the team as they look to blend solid prospects with established players.