The Pfister Hotel in Milwaukee continues to capture the imagination of Major League Baseball players, particularly with its notorious reputation for ghostly occurrences. This came to light recently when Dodgers outfielder Teoscar Hernández shared his skepticism about the hotel’s spooky reputation during a pregame interview before Game 2 of the National League Championship Series. While Hernández himself claims not to have had any supernatural experiences during his stays, he noted that his wife preferred they find alternative accommodations, citing tales of lights flickering and mysterious noises that have circulated among players.
This echoes the sentiments of other MLB stars who have opted to avoid staying at the Pfister due to its haunted reputation. Dodgers infielder Mookie Betts, for instance, is known to choose Airbnb options instead, while other players have echoed similar findings through their own unsettling experiences.
Since its opening in 1893, the Pfister Hotel has been a favored lodging for MLB teams visiting Milwaukee, but not without tales of the eerie. Many players share stories of strange happenings, from lights turning on and off without explanation to hearing unnerving noises during the night. Notable players like Adrian Beltre, who reported knocking at his door, and Bryce Harper, who woke up to find his clothes moved across the room, have all contributed to the hotel’s storied atmosphere.
The hotel’s ghostly reputation can be traced back to numerous episodes involving former players. For instance, C.J. Wilson described a night where he encountered flickering lights and scratching sounds in the walls. More recent tales from players like Brent Rooker and Vinnie Pasquantino illustrate that the strange occurrences persist, contributing to an unwelcome but entertaining narrative about the historic building.
While players may joke about the supernatural experiences, admits to being unsettled, many approach the Pfister with a blend of humor and trepidation. Even as players like Jace Peterson plan pranks targeting teammates like Shelby Miller resting in the hotel, it remains a popular and storied venue in the league.
The unique blend of history, charm, and the flicker of the unexplained makes the Pfister Hotel not just a place to stay but an integral part of the local culture and the lore surrounding visiting teams. As the discussions around experiences continue, it offers a light-hearted reminder of how some traditions endure through spooky tales, blending sport with spectral curiosity.