Peacemaker: Season 2 brings John Cena back as the eponymous DC Comics antihero, continuing as a spinoff within the newly branded DC Universe. Early critics acknowledge a mixed but predominantly positive response, praising Cena’s performance, the character-driven ensemble, and the sharper blend of R-rated humor and action that fans first fell for in the first season.
How it compares to the first season
Critics largely agree that Season 2 is stronger in several respects. It’s described as somehow even better, with a heightened focus on character arcs, a darker and more brutal tone, and deeper emotional throughlines. The season leans into heart and humanity, while still delivering the offbeat humor and daring takes that define the show.
What makes Season 2 feel different
The season is highlighted as more grounded in its core cast, even with interdimensional and multiversal threads in play. It’s noted for heartwarming, humane moments and for giving the ensemble more room to breathe. The shift toward character-based storytelling keeps the story intimate despite expansive sci-fi concepts, earning praise for the way it treats its protagonists with greater vulnerability.
Action and humor
Action remains a selling point: fight choreography is impressive, with gore that’s still in keeping with the show’s unapologetic tone. Some critics predict Season 2 may push for even more brutal eliminations, while others note the action remains inventive despite a modest budget. On humor, the series retains its dark, silly edge; the tonal balance lands differently for some viewers, with a few critics feeling it isn’t as funny as Season 1, while others praise its sharper wit and relentless verbal jabs.
Connecting to the wider DC Universe
Season 2 doubles down on a DC primer that ties into the broader DCU, weaving in references and surprises for longtime fans and newcomers alike. Critics point to the season as a bridge to the bigger cinematic universe, with a sense that Gunn has long been preparing for a central role within the DC stability and continuity.
Writing and structure
The writing is described as more mature, with a parallel-universe storyline that remains engaging and unpredictable. There are notes that the plotting in the early episodes stays lean to keep the ensemble in the foreground, and a few criticisms that some sequences don’t land as hard as others or that certain narrative risks don’t fully pay off. Some observers note moments where the focus on Peacemaker’s journey can sideline the rest of the core group.
Cast and new faces
Returning players are praised for their consistency, with Harcourt (Jennifer Holland) delivering standout moments even as her arc isn’t as strong this season. Danielle Brooks remains a core emotional anchor. Newcomers also attract attention: David Denman and Tim Meadows are highlighted for strong turns, with Meadows’ Langston Fleury offering a memorable, bird-blind gag that critics found funny and offbeat. Overall, the fresh faces add energy and new dynamics to the team.
Seasonal problems
A recurring critique is that the season could use a more cohesive relationship among the core five, with some reviewers wishing for more balance between Peacemaker’s personal journey and the ensemble’s interwoven arcs. There’s also a light disappointment among some critics that Vigilante doesn’t appear as prominently as expected.
Release and future
Peacemaker: Season 2 premieres on HBO Max on August 21, 2025. Fans can expect a continuation of the show’s distinctive mix of dark humor, brutal action, and character-driven storytelling, set against the backdrop of the expanding DCU.
Summary and outlook
Overall, Peacemaker Season 2 is seen as a confident, character-centric upgrade that enriches the DCU while keeping the edge that made the first season memorable. Cena’s performance is repeatedly singled out as a career-best turn, and the ensemble chemistry—alongside strong new performers—helps elevate the series within the evolving DC landscape. For viewers craving a bold, unapologetic superhero show that blends humor, heart, and high-stakes action, Season 2 offers a promising continuation with room to grow.
Possible positive takeaway
If you enjoyed Season 1 for its audacious tone and strong cast, Season 2 delivers even more depth, sharper writing, and a broader DCU payoff, making it a standout entry in contemporary superhero television.
Optional note for editors
Consider highlighting the season as both a continuation and an expansion of the DCU, underscoring Cena’s evolving portrayal and the show’s move toward more interconnected storytelling within the new DC landscape. A short spotlight on Langston Fleury and the dynamic introduced by Tim Meadows could also appeal to readers curious about new supporting characters.