As the 2025 MLB trade deadline approaches, San Diego Padres general manager A.J. Preller is under pressure to make significant moves. Rival executives argue that Preller needs to act swiftly, especially with future Hall of Famer Manny Machado in his prime and several key pitchers heading towards free agency. Additionally, the Los Angeles Dodgers, the reigning World Series champions, appear more vulnerable than anticipated, creating an urgent environment for the Padres.
Historically, Preller is known for his proactive approach, often making bold moves regardless of his contract duration or player availability. His usual strategy involves evaluating every player, including his own, and being open to both buying and selling, operating without hesitation.
Preller’s objectives are clear. He expressed a desire to add “a bat or two” to enhance the lineup, particularly in left field and at catcher, where the team has struggled. The Padres have been exploring trades for potential free agents, including right-hander Michael King and first baseman Luis Arraez, which is consistent with Preller’s willingness to adjust his roster.
Despite the star-studded roster that includes Machado, Fernando Tatis Jr., and Xander Bogaerts, the Padres have struggled offensively, ranking 25th in runs per game. The team’s performance despite hefty contracts for its stars raises questions about their future. Machado, for instance, is set for a significant pay increase in his late career, while Tatis brings a similar financial commitment.
Preller’s track record in reconstructing pitching staff has been notable. He has a history of replacing departing players with new talent at reasonable rates. This has kept the Padres competitive, as demonstrated by their current standing with a solid pitching rotation despite injuries to key players like Joe Musgrove and Dylan Cease.
Cease, who was once a Cy Young contender, might find himself at the center of trade conversations, given his desirability among contending teams. With the Padres’ farm system rated low by analysts, Preller is likely to leverage his existing talent, including Cease, to acquire necessary offensive upgrades. This could be crucial as the team attempts to keep its postseason aspirations alive.
The Padres face substantial challenges, but under Preller’s leadership, they remain in a position to adapt and overcome. His ability to navigate the complexities of team management and create opportunities for improvement might just set the Padres on the right trajectory as the deadline nears. The upcoming days will be pivotal for the organization, and fans are eagerly awaiting the moves Preller will make.