The journey of love often encounters hurdles, and this is certainly true for Noah and Joanne, the central figures in the Los Angeles-set romantic comedy “Nobody Wants This.” Their relationship faces unique challenges, primarily due to their differing backgrounds: Noah is a rabbi, while Joanne is an agnostic sex podcaster, described dismissively by Noah’s mother as a “shiksa,” or a non-Jewish woman.
In the first season, tensions between them escalated when Joanne, after developing feelings for Noah, initially decided to convert to Judaism. However, she later reconsidered, realizing that converting merely for convenience wouldn’t be morally right. This ethical stance led to their breakup, as Joanne did not want Noah to feel torn between his faith and her.
As the new season unfolds, fans might be surprised to find that the emotional cliffhanger of the last season is largely brushed aside. The second season sees Noah and Joanne appearing more settled in their relationship. With both characters in their late thirties, they navigate the ups and downs of everyday life—from hosting a dinner party to Joanne deliberating on whether to discuss Noah’s elegant bedside water carafes on her podcast. Although Noah faces a setback in his aspirations to become head rabbi, he secures a position at a more liberal temple, adding layers to the couple’s dynamic.
Yet, the issue of conversion still lingers. The show’s creator, Erin Foster, draws on her personal experiences with the topic, suggesting that while Joanne may consider exploring Judaism out of love, her skepticism shows she won’t easily adopt the faith overnight. Juxtaposed with this is a somewhat superficial approach presented by Noah’s sister-in-law, Esther, who reduces being Jewish to mere personality traits.
Despite these tensions, “Nobody Wants This” thrives on the captivating chemistry between its leads, Adam Brody and Kristen Bell, reawakening the charm they are known for from their past roles. The character of Morgan, played by Justine Lupe, brings an added comedic depth, along with a new romantic subplot that brings both humor and heart.
The writing in the show continues to impress, with sharp dialogue and relatable observations. While the theological questions at the heart of the narrative are complex, the show remains enjoyable as it balances humor and emotional exploration. Viewers can expect a blend of witty observations and genuine moments as Noah and Joanne navigate their relationship’s intricate tapestry, all while keeping the audience laughing and engaged.