The topic of state taxes in certain NHL cities has gained significant attention lately, particularly following comments from “NHL on TNT” analyst Paul Bissonnette regarding the Florida Panthers players benefiting from no state income tax. NHL commissioner Gary Bettman addressed this issue during a broadcast, calling it a “ridiculous” concern.
Bettman reflected on the years when the Florida teams were less competitive, noting that this tax issue was not brought up during that time. He emphasized that players look for a supportive organization and favorable living conditions rather than focusing solely on tax implications. He acknowledged that while state taxes might play a minor role in a player’s decision, the primary motivations stem from the quality of the team, the training facilities, and the overall environment, including good teammates and coaching.
He also contrasted Florida’s tax situation with cities that have notably high state taxes, such as Los Angeles and New York City, questioning whether the NHL should “subsidize” those franchises. The recent success of teams in the “Sun Belt” region, especially with the Panthers competing in their third consecutive Stanley Cup Final and winning the championship last season, has likely fueled this discussion among fans and analysts.
While the Panthers and the Tampa Bay Lightning, who also dominated the league with three straight Stanley Cup Finals appearances from 2020-22, highlight Florida’s competitive edge, Bettman reminds fans that other teams in no-tax states, like the Dallas Stars, have not fared as well historically, with their last Stanley Cup win dating back to the 1998-99 season.
This conversation not only underscores the complexities of player recruitment in today’s league but also illustrates the ongoing evolution of the NHL, where market conditions and team performance continue to intertwine in shaping the landscape. As teams in warmer climates like Florida find success, it serves as a reminder of the changing dynamics within the sport, encouraging other franchises to reassess their strategies for attracting top talent.