Gary Neville criticized Xavi Simons following a controversial challenge that led to the Tottenham midfielder’s red card during the team’s Premier League match against Liverpool. Simons, in an attempt to tackle Virgil van Dijk, lunged recklessly and scraped his studs down Van Dijk’s calf, missing the ball entirely. Initially, referee John Brooks issued a yellow card, but after a VAR review, he upgraded the decision to a straight red shortly after the half-hour mark, a change Neville fully supported.
On Sky Sports, Neville described the challenge as “poor” and “ridiculous”, emphasizing that Simons had no chance of reaching the ball and instead endangered Van Dijk’s safety. “Malicious, nasty, reckless? Whatever you want to call it,” he said, noting that a challenge of this nature could have serious consequences, especially given Van Dijk’s considerable size advantage.
This incident highlighted Simons’ struggles since his transfer from RB Leipzig for £52 million, managing only a goal and two assists in the Premier League this season. While acknowledging Simons’ difficult season, Neville remarked that the midfielder’s reaction to the game reflected a player who was struggling both on and off the pitch. While some might express frustration over the decision, Neville noted that most Tottenham players accepted the call, recognizing the severity of the challenge as justifiable.
This incident not only underscores the challenges players face in high-pressure matches but also serves as a reminder of the need for precise control and care when tackling to avoid injuries in the sport. The ongoing discussions around player safety and fair play remain essential as the season progresses.