E. Lockhart’s best-selling novel We Were Liars has found new life through a recent television adaptation, which has premiered on Prime Video. Originally released in 2014, the novel surged in popularity thanks to BookTok, a platform where book enthusiasts share their reading experiences, achieving over 21,000 posts related to the title. The eight-episode series, produced by showrunners Julie Plec and Carina Adly Mackenzie, blends elements of teen romance, family drama, and psychological thrills.
Set against the backdrop of an opulent family estate on the fictional Beechwood Island off Martha’s Vineyard, the story revolves around Cadence Sinclair Eastman, portrayed by Emily Alyn Lind. As the eldest grandchild of Harris Sinclair, played by David Morse, Cadence navigates complex family dynamics during summers spent with her cousins, whom they affectionately call “the Liars.” Among the Liars are siblings and close friends, including Gat, who is pivotal to Cadence’s emotional journey.
The plot takes a dark turn during Summer 16 when a series of tragic events unfold, resulting in Cadence suffering a brain injury and selective amnesia. Returning for Summer 17, she embarks on a quest to uncover the traumatic events of the previous summer. Viewers witness her unravel the shocking mystery of how the Liars attempted to burn down the Sinclair mansion in a misguided effort to end family tensions, leading to catastrophic consequences.
By the season finale, Cadence confronts the reality that her memories of camaraderie with the Liars during Summer 17 are merely her mind’s coping mechanism in response to the trauma of losing them. A significant new twist introduces Carrie, who has been interacting with her son Johnny’s ghost, hinting at deeper unresolved issues within the family.
As the show’s narrative progresses, it also delves into the notion of legacy and inheritance, particularly concerning Cadence’s relationship with her grandfather. By choosing to reject her family’s wealth and past, she seeks independence and authenticity in her life, showcasing a strong character development arc.
The adaptation of We Were Liars not only breathes fresh life into a beloved story but also sets the stage for potential exploration of the Sinclair family’s history, especially with the rights to a prequel, Family of Liars, secured by the production team. This could pave the way for a compelling second season that dives into the family’s intricate past and the mysteries that linger on Beechwood Island.