Moana 2 is facing significant challenges as it navigates turbulent legal waters amidst award season. Animator Buck Woodall has filed a lawsuit against Disney, alleging that the studio borrowed elements from his previously copyrighted animated film, “Bucky,” for the Moana movies.
Woodall’s lawsuit, which seeks a staggering $10 billion—or 2.5% of Moana’s gross revenue—accuses Disney of copying crucial plot points and character elements from his 2003 screenplay. His story, set in a Polynesian village, features a determined teenager on a quest to lift a curse, accompanied by spirit animals and a magical demigod wielding a distinctive hook. Similarities have been drawn between “Bucky” and the original Moana film, including common scenes involving turtles and characters navigating ocean whirlpools.
This is not Woodall’s first attempt at legal action; he previously sought to sue Disney during the original Moana’s release but was denied due to a timing issue. However, the release of the sequel has reopened the door to legal proceedings. Disney has countered by asserting the originality of the Moana franchise and submitted evidence to support its position.
Moana director Ron Clements has publicly stated that the film was not influenced by Woodall or his project, asserting that he only became aware of “Bucky” after the lawsuit was initiated.
As the lawsuit unfolds, it threatens to overshadow the upcoming Oscar nominations, which are set to be announced soon. This controversy may jeopardize Moana 2’s chances in the Best Animated Feature or Best Original Song categories.
Overall, the situation reflects ongoing tensions in the creative industry regarding intellectual property and originality, highlighting the importance of defending one’s artistic vision while navigating complex legal landscapes. The resolution of this case may set important precedents for the animation industry and its creators.