On September 24, 2024, Governor Mike Parson announced that the State of Missouri will proceed with the execution of Marcellus Williams, following an order from the Supreme Court of Missouri.
Marcellus Williams was convicted of killing Felicia Gayle on August 11, 1998. He broke into her home, attacked her as she exited the shower, stabbed her 43 times, and left the knife in her neck before stealing items from her residence. Williams was later arrested for a series of robberies in the St. Louis area, leading law enforcement to identify him as the suspect in Gayle’s murder.
Governor Parson stated, “Capital punishment cases are some of the hardest issues we have to address in the Governor’s Office, but when it comes down to it, I follow the law and trust the integrity of our judicial system.” He emphasized that Williams has pursued every legal avenue available to him, attempting to prove his innocence through more than 15 hearings, yet no court or jury has found any merit in his claims of innocence. Parson reiterated that the guilty verdict and death sentence were upheld by the judicial system, asserting that he sees no reason to question Williams’ guilt.
Additionally, Governor Parson expressed concern about the media coverage surrounding the case, noting that Williams’ attorneys have misrepresented DNA evidence, claims that have been dismissed by the courts. He urged media outlets to provide accurate and unbiased reporting based on established facts rather than solely relying on the assertions of those financially or personally invested in Williams’ case.
Williams has consistently maintained his innocence, despite substantial evidence against him, which has been affirmed by numerous legal bodies including a jury, the Missouri Supreme Court, and the St. Louis County Circuit Court. Key points supporting his conviction include:
– Initial DNA testing did not analyze “touch DNA” based on the forensic standards of the time, and subsequent DNA tests have not exonerated him.
– Williams has a significant criminal record, including multiple felonies relate to robbery, armed criminal action, and burglary, which align with the context of Gayle’s murder.
– He confessed to the crime to his girlfriend shortly after it occurred but threatened her to ensure she didn’t report him.
– His girlfriend did not claim a reward for information about the murder, contradicting any claims of financial motivation.
– A jailhouse informant provided information about the murder that was not publicly known but consistent with evidence from the crime scene.
– Witnesses testified to hearing Williams boast about the murder.
– Felicia Gayle’s belongings were found in Williams’ vehicle, along with evidence tying him directly to the crime.
Furthermore, Williams has displayed a pattern of violent behavior in prison, including assaults on other inmates and threats against correctional officers, which underscores his disregard for others’ safety.