The History of Sound, directed by Oliver Hermanus and starring Paul Mescal and Josh O’Connor, premiered at the Cannes Film Festival and tells the story of a same-sex romance set against a musical backdrop in the early 20th century. Recognized as a bold choice for Hollywood, given the sparse representation of period dramas exploring gay relationships since Ang Lee’s Brokeback Mountain two decades ago, the film ultimately feels restrained and almost too polite.
Mescal portrays Lionel, a Kentucky farm boy with exceptional musical talent, while O’Connor plays the confident David, a composition student. The film follows their romantic journey as they navigate love, music, and the upheaval of World War One. While the actors deliver nuanced performances, the film itself lacks emotional depth and urgency, often depicting a picturesque yet superficial version of their relationship.
The narrative unfolds leisurely, presenting Lionel’s decisions regarding his future—whether to pursue music, settle down with David, or return to his family farm—without the dramatic tension one might expect. The film’s pacing drags, and despite its aesthetic beauty, which includes immaculate costumes and settings, the emotional stakes never feel sufficiently high.
Critics pointed out that while the film references the raw essence of folk music, it ironically misses that same passion in its storytelling. The most effective moments arise through the film’s music, with heartfelt ballads serving as a vehicle for emotional resonance that the screenplay struggles to deliver.
Despite its shortcomings, The History of Sound serves as an important step for representation in cinema. Although it may not fully achieve its potential, its existence opens the door for more nuanced explorations of same-sex relationships in period settings.
Overall, while the film boasts a talented cast and lush visuals, it seems to fall short of leaving a lasting emotional impact, reflecting a trend encouraged by contemporary filmmakers to approach sensitive subjects with greater intensity and authenticity.