The Seattle Mariners kicked off their offseason in an exhilarating way by securing Josh Naylor’s services for the long term, a move that fans and analysts alike have hailed as a no-brainer. Naylor’s talents not only enhance the team’s roster but also fit seamlessly into the team’s culture, filling a significant gap at first base with limited options available on the market.
With Naylor’s contract settled, the Mariners can now focus on other strategic moves this winter, and Jorge Polanco has emerged as a pivotal figure in their plans. The veteran player complements the team’s needs excellently, showcasing versatility that the Mariners are keen to leverage. Polanco’s ability to DH on days when Cal Raleigh is behind the plate, alongside playing other positions, makes him a valuable asset, especially as the Mariners look to pair him with youthful talent like Cole Young at second base.
However, Polanco poses a complex decision for the Mariners. At 32 years old, he is projected by MLB.com as the 24th best free agent this offseason. If he seeks a three-year deal, the Mariners could be signing him into his mid-30s, a period when players might face the risk of injuries and performance decline, which has been evident in Polanco’s recent seasons. Although he provided clutch moments in the postseason, his overall numbers revealed a concerning dip in performance, highlighting the challenges the organization might face in ensuring he maintains productivity as he ages.
While many would endorse bringing Polanco back due to his fit within the team, the Mariners are also in a position to be prudent. With Naylor secured, they can afford to stick to their established limits on contract offers without feeling pressured. Alternatives do exist: players like free agent Willi Castro, who has similar capabilities and is younger, could offer different avenues for the Mariners to explore.
The Mariners’ roster is set to undergo changes, and Polanco’s decision will greatly influence their offseason direction. Whether they opt for a different strategy—like a one-year deal for Geno Suarez or pursuing high-caliber talent such as Bo Bichette—will reveal their ambition level this offseason. Addressing needs across several positions, including second, shortstop, third, and both outfield spots, the Mariners find themselves with options in a deep farm system that could lead to exciting trades.
With plenty of questions ahead and an evidently strong roster base, the Mariners are poised for a dynamic offseason that could reshape their standing in 2025. As the hot stove heats up, fans can look forward to an engaging season of anticipation and innovation from the front office.