Brian Kelly’s tenure at LSU has hit a significant low point as the Tigers face increasing challenges in the recruiting landscape. The situation deteriorated further on Thursday night when five-star quarterback Bryce Underwood, who was anticipated to be a major asset for the program in 2025, committed to Michigan. This decision was influenced by Michigan’s lucrative NIL offer estimated at $10 million.
Over the past weeks, LSU has been struggling with a three-game losing streak, which eliminated them from the College Football Playoff contention. Although there have been anxious discussions among fans and analysts regarding Kelly’s performance, experts believe that the recent losses did not directly sway Underwood’s choice. Recruiting analyst Allen Trieu mentioned that the tides were shifting prior to the losing streak and that the situation may have unfolded similarly even if LSU had been victorious.
The Tigers’ failure to maintain their esteemed 2025 recruiting class is causing unrest among the passionate fanbase. Promising recruits like elite wide receiver Derek Meadows and five-star cornerback DJ Pickett are reconsidering their commitments in light of LSU’s recent performance. With National Signing Day approaching on December 4, the program faces considerable uncertainty.
Kelly acknowledged that losing games raises questions about recruiting, emphasizing the importance of maintaining constant communication with players. He referred to the shifting roster dynamics within the Southeastern Conference (SEC), highlighting how NIL and revenue sharing are reshaping team compositions.
The fundamental concerns regarding Kelly’s fit at LSU have intensified, especially after the team struggled against Florida, underscoring the vital role of a strong quarterback. Florida’s freshman quarterback DJ Lagway showcased his potential, emphasizing the need for LSU to find its own star player moving forward.
While Kelly’s contract includes a daunting $60 million buyout, the loss of Underwood diminishes hopes for immediate success. Despite this setback, there are still opportunities for improvement, particularly with potential returnees like Garrett Nussmeier. For LSU to become competitive in the SEC again, substantial upgrades in various positions are necessary.
The current crisis could serve as a wake-up call for Kelly and the LSU program, prompting them to rethink their strategies around NIL funding and recruitment. This moment can inspire a renewed commitment to building a formidable roster, similar to actions taken by Ohio State after setbacks.
Time is of the essence for Kelly to implement a solid Plan B, and his ability to adapt could ultimately determine the future success of the Tigers.
In summary, while the loss of a top recruit is undoubtedly a setback, it could also serve as a pivotal moment for Brian Kelly and LSU to reevaluate their direction and emerge stronger from adversity. With swift action and determination, there remains hope for a brighter future for the program.