Josh Hart has become a focal point of discussion among New York Knicks fans, especially as the team has started the 2023-2024 season with a disappointing 2-3 record. Over the last two and a half seasons, Hart has demonstrated his value with relentless rebounding, adept one-man fast breaks, and a knack for winning loose balls. However, his shortcomings are glaring as well: he struggles as a floor spacer and has exhibited inconsistent defense, complicating evaluations of his overall importance to the team.
Historically, Hart’s strengths have often overshadowed his weaknesses, contributing significantly even when his shooting hasn’t been ideal. Last season, he was a crucial element of the Knicks’ success, and his efforts somehow eased the pain of subpar shooting nights. However, his performance this young season has raised eyebrows, particularly with critical statistics emerging after four games. Currently, Hart is averaging just 2.8 points, 6 rebounds, and 3.3 assists per game, with an alarming shooting line of 21.1% from the field, 10% from three-point range, and 50% from the free-throw line. Additionally, his plus/minus rating is the worst on the team at -36 in only 89 minutes of play.
Fans and analysts alike are calling for improvements as Hart’s struggles have come amidst a stretch of losses. This raises concerns, especially since it seems he has not been particularly effective defensively, either. While some of the blame falls on Hart, head coach Mike Brown also faces scrutiny for allocating him substantial playing time despite his performance. Unlike former coach Tom Thibodeau, whose dependency on Hart irked many fans, Brown has exercised some discretion but still appears to lean on the veteran guard more than necessary for this early stage of the season.
This dynamic has fueled debates among fans regarding Hart’s future in New York. Some have gone so far as to suggest he needs to be traded, questioning whether he is becoming a liability. However, such strong statements may overlook the bigger picture—Hart played a pivotal role in the team’s improvement last season, contributing to their success. As the Knicks navigate a season widely expected to be transformative, Hart’s past contributions should afford him some leeway from the fanbase, at least for now.
Despite the urgency surrounding every Knicks’ loss, there’s a need for fans to maintain a balanced perspective. Emotional reactions can lead to hasty conclusions about a player’s worth, particularly given Hart’s previous contributions. While he has undeniably struggled early this season, it’s essential to recognize that it’s just a few games into an 82-game schedule. This could be an opportunity for him to regroup and regain form.
On the flip side, while Hart enjoys a dedicated following that often defends him, it’s crucial for his supporters to acknowledge when he performs poorly. Dismissing fair criticisms of his current play detracts from the discussions that could help him improve. The passionate Knicks fanbase must find a middle ground: recognizing when Hart’s contributions are invaluable while also addressing the need for improvement when things aren’t working.
The season is still young, and as Hart looks to turn his game around, Knicks fans can remain hopeful for both him and the team as they navigate what could be one of the most pivotal seasons in franchise history.