Ryan Murphy’s latest series, “All’s Fair,” featuring Kim Kardashian, has faced a barrage of criticism from critics and television journalists alike, with many calling it “existentially terrible,” “tacky,” and a “disaster zone.” The legal drama, which is now streaming its first three episodes on Hulu and Disney+, centers around a group of female divorce attorneys in Los Angeles who establish their own firm, tackling high-stakes breakups, scandalous secrets, and internal conflicts within their team.
Despite a star-studded cast that includes Naomi Watts, Niecy Nash-Betts, Teyana Taylor, Sarah Paulson, and Glenn Close, many reviews have panned the performances, particularly Kardashian’s portrayal of divorce attorney Allura Grant. Critics have harshly described her acting as stilted, and the dialogue has been dismissed as a “tsunami of clunking cliché.” Ben Dowell of The Times went so far as to label the show the “worst television drama ever made,” articulating the show’s failed attempt to offer a feminist narrative while embodying the very greed and vanity it seeks to critique.
Lucy Mangan from The Guardian echoed Dowell’s sentiments, remarking on the show’s inability to meet even basic standards of television, characterizing it as “terrible” and “existentially terrible.” The Telegraph’s Ed Power contributed to the negative reception by suggesting that Kardashian’s involvement is just one element within an overall disastrous production, which has left audiences unimpressed and bewildered.
Despite the bleak reviews from prominent media outlets, new episodes of “All’s Fair” will continue to be released every Tuesday on Hulu and Disney+. This presents an opportunity for viewers to form their own opinions on the series, even as critical engagement remains heavily skeptical. The strong reactions to the show indicate a significant division in audience perception, with some likely drawn to the novelty of Kardashian’s presence within the legal drama format.
While the critical landscape currently appears unfavorable, there is always potential for the series to evolve and find its footing as new episodes unfold. The ongoing discussions surrounding the show may inspire a deeper examination of its themes and character arcs in future installments.