Brian Kelly’s tenure at LSU has taken a significant downturn in his third season, worsened by the recent decision of five-star recruit Bryce Underwood to commit to Michigan. Underwood, ranked as the top recruit for the class of 2025, reportedly received an NIL package from Michigan worth around $10 million, proving to be a substantial loss for the Tigers.
In light of LSU’s current struggles, which include a three-game losing streak that has knocked the team out of the College Football Playoff race, questions about Kelly’s leadership and recruiting abilities have intensified among the fanbase. While some speculate that the losing streak and Kelly’s emotional sideline reactions influenced Underwood’s decision, recruiting analyst Allen Trieu suggests that this situation had likely been brewing long before these events occurred.
The Tigers’ recruiting class, which initially appeared promising with multiple five-star players, now faces uncertainty as elite wide receiver Derek Meadows is reportedly considering other options, and Miami and other schools are vying for cornerback DJ Pickett, who is currently committed to LSU.
This tumultuous period raises concerns about the adequacy of the coaching staff’s recruitment strategy, particularly with a head coach like Kelly earning a considerable $10 million salary. In response to these challenges, Kelly acknowledged that constant communication with the recruiting class is crucial, given the changes in the current landscape of college football due to NIL and revenue sharing.
While Kelly’s fit at LSU has been questioned, particularly following reports of a disconnect between his coaching style and the expectations in Baton Rouge, there remains some hope. Despite recent setbacks, it’s vital to keep faith in potential future star players. Garrett Nussmeier, expected to inherit the starting quarterback position, could emerge as a vital asset, provided he improves his gameplay.
LSU’s leadership may also respond to this setback by stepping up their NIL efforts, potentially leading to a major reinvestment in the program to attract top talent. It’s essential for Kelly to navigate this challenging period effectively and find a way to regroup.
Overall, while the loss of Underwood is disappointing, it provides an opportunity for the LSU program to reassess and recalibrate. With the right adjustments and a renewed focus on recruiting, there remains a chance for LSU to reclaim its competitive edge in the SEC and beyond. The clock is ticking, but with resilience and strategic planning, brighter days could still lie ahead for the Tigers.