A sense of disillusionment is emerging among some Jewish communities in America as they reflect on their safety and treatment in the country amidst a rise in antisemitism. The author, now living in Israel, expresses feelings of greater security in their new home, contrasting it with their past experiences in what was once perceived as a land of liberty.
Recent instances of violent antisemitic acts have raised questions about the response from the American public and leaders. Notable attacks include the firebombing of Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro’s home, the tragic shooting of Israeli Embassy staff outside the Capital Jewish Museum in Washington, D.C., and a disturbing assault in Boulder, Colorado, where a man aimed a flamethrower at demonstrators, heavily targeted Jews, and prepared for the attack for a year.
Despite these alarming events, there seems to be a lack of widespread public outrage comparable to the responses witnessed during other social justice movements. Many are asking why, when Jews are victimized, the national dialogue does not engage with the same intensity as other pressing societal issues.
The author reflects on the historical connection that many Jews have felt with the United States, a place once viewed as a sanctuary where they could thrive without fear. Now, as they witness an indifference to violence against Jews, they question whether that safety was ever more than an illusion.
In this challenging moment, the author advocates for Jewish pride and unity, suggesting that instead of seeking validation in a society that appears increasingly hostile toward them, Jewish people should embrace their identity and history, looking toward Israel as a place of security and belonging. They emphasize the importance of standing together in the face of adversity and reclaiming their narrative as a sovereign people.
As the dialogue evolves around these complex issues, it is apparent that the Jewish community is at a crossroads, facing a choice between remaining in a potentially hostile environment or embracing their heritage and identity with dignity in a land that values their existence.