James L. Brooks makes a much-anticipated return to feature filmmaking with his latest project, Ella McCay, after a 15-year hiatus. His previous film, How Do You Know, released in 2010, received mixed reviews and showcased the struggles some directors face as they approach the later stages of their careers. However, Brooks, known for crafting classics like Terms of Endearment, Broadcast News, and As Good As It Gets, demonstrates he still has the touch with this new film.
Starring Emma Mackey as the titular character, a politician thrust into the role of governor following the resignation of her boss, played by Albert Brooks, Ella McCay is set against the backdrop of 2008. The film addresses a time that the narrator, voiced by Julie Kavner, describes as an era when, “We all still liked each other,” offering a contrast to the more divisive atmosphere of recent years. While the film captures the essence of a more optimistic time, it is not a political commentary in itself but rather focuses on personal stories intertwined with political elements.
A common narrative surrounding Brooks has been skepticism regarding the relevance of veteran filmmakers, with some questioning why they don’t choose to retire when their best work seems behind them. This sentiment mirrors that expressed towards other directors, such as Quentin Tarantino, who has discussed public expectations regarding their careers. Despite the trailer for Ella McCay facing criticism, Brooks brings his signature craftsmanship to this film, ensuring it stands as a testament to his enduring talent.
Over the years, Brooks has maintained a busy schedule, particularly with his role overseeing The Simpsons, yet his commitment to Ella McCay has been unwavering. The film showcases his meticulous filmmaking style, characterized by a focus on nuanced human behavior rather than relying on flashy visuals or melodrama. Mackey’s character undergoes minimal dramatic changes but is supported by a stellar ensemble cast that includes Jamie Lee Curtis, Kumail Nanjiani, Woody Harrelson, and others, all of whom bring their unique talents to the film.
Curtis, in particular, delivers a standout performance, encapsulating the “Brooksian Touch” that has defined many of his successful projects. The film has been noted for its engaging ensemble rather than solely focusing on the lead character’s journey in politics, suggesting a broader interpretation of relationships and personal dynamics.
There are rumors that the film’s production was tied to Brooks’ agreement to create a second Simpsons Movie, slated for release in summer 2027, showcasing the enduring influence of Brooks’ work in contemporary popular culture. While Ella McCay may currently face mixed reviews, similar to how some of Stanley Kubrick’s films were initially received, there is hope that appreciation for Brooks’ artistry will grow over time. At 85 years old, Brooks may not have many films left in him, but his ability to bring magic to the screen remains undeniable.