The departure of a task force at the Heritage Foundation has highlighted a growing divide within the conservative movement regarding support for Israel. This rift has become particularly pronounced between traditional conservatives who have historically backed the Jewish state and those aligned with former President Trump’s “America First” principles, which often call for a reevaluation of U.S. foreign aid, including support for Israel.
In a recent video, Mr. Roberts, a prominent figure in the foundation, stated that conservatives are under no obligation to support foreign governments, regardless of pressure from what he termed the “globalist class” or their allies in Washington. He referred to Mr. Carlson, a key member of the conservative media landscape, as a “close friend” of the Heritage Foundation and accused critics of attacking him of creating divisions within the party.
Roberts’ comments sparked significant backlash, with accusations of perpetuating antisemitic themes emerging from across the political spectrum. The fallout led to the resignation of at least five task force members and considerable discontent among the foundation’s staff.
In response to the uproar, Roberts issued an apology, expressing a willingness to resign but also a desire to mend the rifts his statements had caused. He addressed the matter during a staff meeting and in a follow-up video, aiming to reaffirm his commitment to the foundation’s unity and mission.
This discord within the conservative ranks indicates a significant shift in the political landscape, where debates over traditional policies are increasingly influenced by emerging populist sentiments. It remains to be seen how this internal conflict will shape the future direction of the Heritage Foundation and the broader conservative movement, particularly in relation to foreign policy and support for Israel. As the landscape evolves, it presents an opportunity for dialogue and redefinition of core values within conservatism, fostering an environment where diverse perspectives can coexist.