Matthew Schaefer is quickly becoming a standout player in the NHL, earning significant praise for his performance with the New York Islanders. The rookie defenseman has tallied five points in five games and boasts an impressive average of over 22 minutes on the ice per game. This strong start is particularly remarkable considering he played in only 17 games during the 2024-25 season, which raised doubts about his readiness for the NHL.
Elliotte Friedman, during a recent episode of the 32 Thoughts podcast, highlighted Schaefer as one of the most impressive players this season, noting that while he may not yet be the best player on the Islanders, his impact has been undeniable. Friedman remarked, “He has made an immediate impact and he has breathed life into the franchise.” This is significant, as the Islanders already had talented players like goaltender Ilya Sorokin and forwards Mathew Barzal and Simon Holmstrom, but none have burst onto the scene like Schaefer has in his rookie year.
While Friedman mentioned Schaefer’s importance, he wisely refrained from declaring him the team’s best player just yet. As a rookie defenseman, Schaefer will encounter the typical challenges that come with transitioning to the NHL, including inevitable fluctuations in performance. Despite this, he has instilled confidence in fans, showcasing the potential to overcome future hurdles.
Schaefer’s performance thus far has drawn comparisons with other top players like Seth Jarvis and Shane Pinto, who are enjoying successful starts in the league. However, Schaefer’s journey to the NHL was unique. He only emerged as a top draft pick on the day of the 2025 NHL Draft, when the Islanders traded away Noah Dobson, placing further emphasis on the significance of his immediate success.
While it’s essential for fans to remain realistic about Schaefer’s development, his early statistics are encouraging. With a 55.8 Corsi For percentage and a solid shooting percentage of 12.5, he has already contributed significantly on offense. Yet, as with any rookie, defensive improvements are necessary. Schaefer has allowed seven even-strength goals and has seen his on-ice save percentage rated at 81.1, indicating room for growth.
In summary, fans of the New York Islanders have much to be excited about with Schaefer’s early performances. His ability to adapt and grow as a player will be crucial as the season progresses, but his current impact suggests a bright future ahead for both him and the franchise.