FOX Sports host Jason McIntyre sparked a heated debate on The Herd by declaring Jalen Hurts “the best dual-threat quarterback the league has ever seen,” citing Hurts’ four straight seasons with at least 15 passing touchdowns and 10 rushing touchdowns.
McIntyre’s argument hinges on Hurts’ comprehensive skill set and durability, but context matters. Hurts has logged 55 rushing touchdowns in his career, and 33 of those have come with the Eagles’ signature goal-line push known as the Tush Push. While the play showcases Hurts’ remarkable lower-body strength, critics say it inflates his rushing totals compared with dual-threat peers who scored rushing TDs through a wider mix of carries and designs.
Hurts’ production does come with some important context. He operates behind one of the league’s strongest offensive lines and within an offense that routinely leverages designed runs and sequence-based play calling. Proponents argue that Hurts’ value goes beyond raw numbers, highlighting leadership, decision-making, and the ability to keep defenses honest with both his arm and his legs.
Still, the conversation around his rushing TDs underscores a broader theme in evaluating dual-threat quarterbacks: numbers don’t tell the entire story. Hurts is undeniably a useful and efficient asset for an Eagles roster that remains stacked at nearly every position, but attributing the entirety of his rushing success to individual talent may overlook the role of system, o-line play, and goal-line strategy.
What to watch next: insiders have teased that the Eagles could be involved in a “really good trade,” which may further shape the team’s trajectory and Hurts’ supporting cast.
Key takeaways
– McIntyre’s bold claim centers on Hurts’ four consecutive seasons with at least 15 passing TDs and 10 rushing TDs.
– A large portion of Hurts’ rushing TDs have come from the Tush Push, a short-yardage play that emphasizes the offense’s physical edge.
– Hurts’ effectiveness is sometimes framed as a combination of talent and environment—elite athleticism paired with an outstanding offensive line and well-crafted play design.
– The debate highlights a larger question in evaluating dual-threat quarterbacks: how much weight should be given to rushing totals that arise from specialized short-yardage plays?
Overall, Hurts remains a central figure in the Eagles’ ongoing success, with supporters pointing to leadership and all-around impact, while critics call for a fuller view of how rushing TDs are earned. If the Eagles continue to bolster around him and maintain their offensive strengths, Hurts’ place in the conversation among dual-threat quarterbacks will likely endure.