In the new film “Heretic,” two young missionaries from the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints find themselves ensnared in a harrowing psychological game with a charming yet sinister stranger named Mr. Reed, portrayed by Hugh Grant. The story unravels as Sisters Paxton and Barnes, played by Chloe East and Sophie Thatcher respectively, accept an apparently innocent invitation to Reed’s home, only to discover that their visit is anything but benign.
Initially, the sisters believe they are engaging in a discussion about their faith, but Mr. Reed soon reveals his ulterior motives, becoming increasingly confrontational and forcing them to listen to his critique of various religions. The tension escalates as the sisters realize their lives may hinge on a choice between belief and disbelief, and they must outsmart their captor to escape.
Chloe East, who has ties to the LDS faith, reflects on the film’s depth, emphasizing its ability to elicit varying interpretations based on individual backgrounds. The screenplay, co-written by Scott Beck and Bryan Woods—who previously created “A Quiet Place”—delves into themes of manipulation and control, positioning Mr. Reed as a self-righteous zealot, despite his critiques. This complexity resonated with East, who found the script encouraged open dialogue rather than presenting a one-sided viewpoint.
As the plot thickens, the sisters face increasingly horrific scenarios designed to test their beliefs. Eventually, they confront their own perceptions as they navigate a series of challenges posed by Mr. Reed, including witnessing a disturbing resurrection attempt that ultimately reveals his true nature.
In a climactic showdown, Sister Paxton uses her cunning to escape, but not without significant peril. The film concludes with a haunting scene as Paxton encounters a butterfly, evoking earlier references that intertwine concepts of reality and existence, leaving viewers with a sense of ambiguity that invites personal interpretation.
The film’s open-ended conclusion allows for diverse interpretations of faith, sacrifice, and survival. As East noted, audience experiences will vary, opening avenues for discussions on faith and the human psyche. “Heretic” ultimately presents a thought-provoking narrative that challenges conventional beliefs and invites viewers to reflect on their own perspectives.
In a landscape of films addressing complex themes, “Heretic” stands out for its unique blend of psychological thriller and philosophical exploration. Its plot encourages open dialogue about faith and personal conviction, catering to audiences from different backgrounds. While it grapples with heavy subject matter, the film’s exploration of resilience and the power of belief leaves a hopeful message about the strength of the human spirit in the face of adversity.