James Hagens entered the year as a highly-touted prospect for the 2025 NHL Draft, often considered a favorite for the top pick. However, as draft week approaches, there is a growing sentiment that Hagens may not be a top-five selection. This change in perception reflects the emergence of other talented prospects who have outperformed expectations this season.
Last year, Hagens had a remarkable season with the USA Hockey National Team Development Program, amassing 102 points, a feat accomplished without elite linemates typically seen among the top scorers. His impressive performance extended to the international stage, where he achieved record-setting offensive numbers at the 2022 U-17 World Challenge and the 2024 U-18 World Championship. Despite the high expectations set by his previous accomplishments, some now deem him underrated.
Dan Muse, Hagens’ former coach at the USNTDP and current coach of the Pittsburgh Penguins, praised Hagens for his exceptional vision, hockey IQ, and high-end skating ability. After his freshman season at Boston College, where he scored 37 points in 37 games, comparisons to recent first-round picks like Macklin Celebrini and even players like Jack Hughes and Logan Cooley have emerged. While Hagens showcased great potential during the season, he fell short of the anticipated offensive output, in part due to the standout performance of his linemates, who have now made their NHL debuts.
Scouts still recognize Hagens as a top prospect, with some placing him at fourth on Daily Faceoff’s final draft rankings. At 5-foot-10.5 and 186 pounds, he has matured physically but still lacks the muscle seen in some of his peers. However, his skating finesse and playmaking abilities remain significant assets that could elevate his draft stock. Hagens demonstrated moments of brilliance when able to control the pace of the game, positioned as a potentially transformative playmaker next season without the distraction of his high-caliber teammates.
Former teammates offer insight into Hagens’ game, highlighting his exceptional awareness and ability to slow down play when in possession. As he prepares for the upcoming draft, he has a unique opportunity to establish himself as a leading player at Boston College and perhaps reconnect with fellow USNTDP prospect Teddy Stiga.
The upcoming 2025 NHL Draft presents Hagens with a chance to prove his critics wrong and live up to the high expectations once placed upon him, making him a compelling pick for teams searching for a dynamic center capable of thriving in the NHL. Fans and analysts alike eagerly anticipate the draft, and many believe that the team fortunate enough to select Hagens will be making a smart investment in their future.