The Cleveland Guardians are set to host the Milwaukee Brewers on May 12, 2025, at Progressive Field, with the first pitch scheduled for 6:10 p.m. ET. The game will be broadcast on CLEG.
Following a disappointing performance on Sunday, the Guardians aim to bounce back against the Brewers, who recently secured a victory against the Tampa Bay Rays. Both teams are currently positioned in second place within their respective divisions.
In terms of pitching, the game will feature the Brewers’ right-hander Freddy Peralta, who boasts an impressive 2.18 ERA over eight starts this season, and the Guardians’ Ben Lively, noted for his role as a dependable innings eater despite concerns over his declining metrics that indicate the potential for upcoming struggles.
The Guardians present a mixed picture overall. With a 23-17 record, they have been performing well, yet their negative run differential of -15 raises questions about their sustainability. Cleveland’s offense has experienced inconsistency; although they’ve shown flashes of brilliance this month, they faltered in their last two games, managing only a single run combined against the Phillies.
From the Brewers’ perspective, their hitting has lagged significantly, ranking last for May with a dismal 48 wRC+. However, as they prepare to face Lively, a pitcher who has yet to fully harness his capabilities this season, there is hope that their bats will awaken.
A bright spot for the Guardians is their lineup, which features players like José Ramírez and Steven Kwan, who have histories of strong performances at the plate. Meanwhile, Peralta’s strong performance on the mound gives Milwaukee an edge, making him a critical player to watch as he aims to maintain his form without further injury setbacks.
In betting terms, analysts favor the Brewers with a moneyline of -130, reflecting the perceived advantage from their starting pitcher. As both teams enter this matchup, it promises to be a critical test, particularly for Cleveland as they seek to solidify their playoff aspirations while the Brewers hope to find rhythm in their offense.
Overall, the Guardians and Brewers matchup presents an interesting dynamic, reminiscent of recent games where both teams faced challenges but also clear opportunities for improvement. This game could be a turning point, especially for Milwaukee, whose offense desperately needs to recover.