The New York Giants are navigating a delicate balance with their top rookie, Abdul Carter, trying to maximize his impact without exposing him excessively on special teams. Carter, drafted third overall in the 2025 NFL draft, has been an asset for the Giants, but concerns have been raised about his involvement in special teams, particularly after taking hard hits in punt blocks during the Giants’ Week 2 loss to the Dallas Cowboys.
Dan Duggan of The Athletic highlighted the risks of deploying Carter too frequently in special teams roles, noting instances where Carter appeared vulnerable to potentially injurious play. With Carter’s potential as a major playmaker for the Giants, it’s crucial that his use be carefully managed to keep him healthy and focused on his primary role—pressuring quarterbacks.
While Carter has shown promise, producing pressures and hurries in pass-rushing situations, the Giants face a challenge. His dynamic capabilities were evident when he blocked a punt against the Washington Commanders in Week 1, showcasing the potential impact he can have on special teams. However, with key injuries affecting the Giants’ defensive depth and the loss of special teams leader Chris Board, the temptation to overuse Carter in various roles is strong.
The Giants’ defense, struggling in early games, needs bolstering. With nearly 100 more yards allowed than any other team and substantial points surrendered, improving the unit’s effectiveness is paramount. Despite an underwhelming pressure rate, there have been bright spots such as sacks and quarterback hits. Giving Carter more opportunities within base and sub-package defenses could elevate overall defensive performance.
As the Giants aim for a turnaround, strategically deploying Carter where he can have the most significant impact while protecting his health is vital. He needs to transition from a promising rookie to a cornerstone player primarily dedicated to enhancing the Giants’ pass rush, ultimately allowing the team to overcome their early defensive challenges.