As Week 9 of the NFL season approaches, Yahoo analyst Matt Harmon highlights five intriguing quarterback situations that fantasy football managers should monitor closely.
The New Orleans Saints have opted to give rookie Tyler Shough the starting position for the remainder of the season after pulling Spencer Rattler mid-game during their Week 8 loss to the Buccaneers. This move allows the Saints to evaluate Shough, whom they drafted 40th overall in the 2025 NFL Draft, before potentially making a quarterback selection in the top five next April. Despite recent turnovers, Rattler had performed adequately, ranking 15th among quarterbacks with a 47.1% success rate. While his performance did not warrant a benching, the Saints will hope Shough can inject new energy into their offense and maintain the success of key players like Chris Olave.
In Arizona, Kyler Murray returns as the starting quarterback following the bye week. This transition raises questions about his performance and potential job security, especially as the franchise is at a crucial juncture. Although backup Jacoby Brissett did not elevate the team’s performance, his two-game stint showed promising numbers. Murray now has a significant opportunity to demonstrate he can reclaim his position effectively. The upcoming matchup against the Cowboys, known for their leaky defense, might be just what Murray needs to showcase his skills and secure his standing.
The Minnesota Vikings are seeing J.J. McCarthy return as the starting quarterback after Carson Wentz was placed on season-ending IR. McCarthy’s earlier performance was troubling, with the Vikings averaging only 16.5 points per game. However, now he has a chance to display improved play over a longer stretch. The Vikings are not playoff contenders this year, so it’s essential to assess McCarthy’s potential and how it may influence their offseason quarterback decisions.
The Atlanta Falcons continue to be a puzzle, struggling with inconsistent performances throughout the season, reflected in their negative point differential. With quarterback Michael Penix Jr. striving to regain form, the focus shifts to ensuring star receiver Drake London is targeted more consistently. Despite previous successes, the team has faltered in crucial moments. With an upcoming matchup against the Patriots, who allow a high number of points per dropback, the Falcons need to capitalize and revitalize their offense.
Finally, the Chicago Bears find themselves amid discussions surrounding Caleb Williams and his future. Although there is no change at quarterback, Justin Fields has seen progress, showing potential despite earlier struggles. The Bears face a favorable matchup against the Bengals’ defense, which has proven vulnerable. Fields needs to continue developing his passing game, particularly in making timely decisions to maximize the opportunities available to him, especially with a potent offense scheme designed to exploit the Bengals.
These quarterback situations could significantly influence fantasy football lineups moving forward, and insights into their performances will be essential for managers looking to capitalize on the ongoing shifts in the league.