The drama continues to unfold in the hit reality show “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives,” particularly between former close friends Jessi Ngatikaura and Demi Engemann. Their relationship took a notable turn in the previous season after they had a falling out, and their interactions this season have caught the attention of fans.
Demi Engemann has been active on social media, commenting on various videos and insinuating that the show may be more scripted than it claims. In response, Jessi decided to address some of these insinuations publicly. In a recent Instagram Story, Jessi wrote, “Honey, just because you script YOURSELF doesn’t mean our show is scripted. This behavior, level of delusion, and downward spiral should be studied.” This statement reflects the tension between the two women as the narrative of the show continues to evolve.
The fallout between them has led to some explosive revelations. During season 1, Demi had shared a provocative story involving her husband Bret Engemann and a box of Fruity Pebbles, the details of which were murky and left fans speculating. Now, Jessi seems to have taken it upon herself to elaborate on that story, claiming, “So since she wants to be petty and be an a——, I think I’m just going to go ahead and say that Grandpa Bret likes to drink her piss like it’s dirty soda, and he gulps it down like water.” This shocking assertion certainly adds fuel to the fire of their ongoing feud.
In retaliation, Demi defended her initial experiences, stating in an Instagram post, “What my husband and I did one-time behind closed doors was a consensual and private experience in our marriage.” She also alleged that Jessi’s decision to bring this up now is a diversion from her own controversial actions.
This isn’t the first time the Fruity Pebbles topic has caused tension; it previously sparked a dispute between Demi and Whitney Leavitt, who jokingly gifted her the cereal after hearing about the incident. At the time, Demi expressed her discomfort with the public discussions around her private life, saying, “I take full accountability that I’m the one who opened the can of worms, but it does bother me the way that Whitney went about that.”
As the fans engage with the new season streaming on Hulu, it’s clear that “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives” remains a source of entertainment, intrigue, and controversy. With a new season set to premiere in early 2026, viewers can expect more dramatic storylines and unexpected twists from the cast. The evolving dynamics and revelations serve not only as entertainment but also as a curious look into personal narratives and friendship tensions in the public eye.